00:00
35
More
See all Show me
Watch first, then continue reading, please.
.
.
.
.
.
As artists, animators, designers and other creatives, we are often called upon to lend our talents and skills to give a new face to a product, a company, or an idea. We make political campaign ads. We make soft drink commercials. We make internal videos for fortune 500 companies. We donate our time to promote small things we feel great about, yet also work to rebrand some of the worst corporations on earth. We do both of these things because it is part of the business. One day it's a friendly, green face on a known polluter and the next it's a designer brand that wants to look like a grassroots social movement. Sometimes it's a music video whose depiction of women is questionable, sometimes it's a political ad whose facts we know are not quite right.

What responsibility do we have in this, if any? I'm not condemning anyone in particular, and I'm not saying we need some sort of vice squad roaming around calling one another out. But I've talked to so many people in this business who see themselves as just a tool to be used, no more than a sentient, albeit creative, installation of Photoshop. But we are more than our copies of Adobe Creative Suite. We are more than our pencils. We are more than our workstations and our client list. We are sentient, choosing people. Our talent is powerful. But we're often more interested in how big the name is, how big the paycheck is, and how creative we can be that we can forget what our real impact is. Is being a professional putting aside our own hangups and doing work for clients with whom we actively disagree, or is that giving up a part of ourselves that is acutely human? Are such ideals a sign of naivete, or something precious to be guarded?

So think about it. Have a line somewhere, or have a reason not to have one. If you're cool with what you're doing - awesome! Have a blast and make great things! I look forward to seeing them! But please, think before you rebrand. Do it because you choose to, not simply because it's your function. We've all been there, but it's a discussion that doesn't seem to happen enough.

Feel free to leave questions or comments.

To answer a frequently asked question, all of the art and animation and even that weird tone at the end was made in After Effects.

And lastly: Yes, I think segregation is terrible- morally, socially, philosophically and historically. That's why I picked it. To show how easily - through cute, approachable, creative advertising - something truly horrifying can be rebranded, repackaged and promoted. And whose responsibility is that - the client who ordered it, the artist who made it, the viewer who accepted it, or none, or all?

Credits

Likes

See all likes
  • Denman Rooke plus 1 year ago
    Great piece of work. Your use of animation, art, and linguistic expression together, crafted a very nice presentation. The point you have here is a great one.
  •  
  • Nicole Novak 1 year ago
    One of the most valuable things we have is often sold or traded away for something so little. Your integrity is inspiring.
  • Scott Benson plus 1 year ago
    Your description here is much more concise that what I wrote up top. Bravo!
  •  
  • Tom Judd plus 1 year ago
    Great stuff Scott. It's a super example of how vimeo can be used to fire up some real discussion between fellow creatives. Shared on animade.tv
  • Scott Benson plus 1 year ago
    Thanks so much!
  •  
  • dunkwun 1 year ago
    thanks for expressing this here in a public forum.
    as am about to enter into this industry i am beginning to wonder how any one is going to actually benefit from any of this, or even worse, if i am just feeding the system by pursuing such a career. I just never had the ability to pin-point or articulate what I was feeling.
    really great work, man.
  •  
  • Charles Huettner 1 year ago
    well made and well said. I've only come across this sort of thing once, but it was enough to make me want to find a different line of work.
  •  
  • beeple plus 1 year ago
    way to put yer balls out there dude! :)
  • Scott Benson plus 1 year ago
    totally.
  •  
  • Vincent Lammers 1 year ago
    This made me smile, think and inspired. thank you very much Mr. Benson.

    Make it grand.
  •  
  • electrorouge 1 year ago
    Nice thoughts and yes, we are able to transform horrible things in a cute story (remember Chaplin with The Dictator).
    We try!
  •  
  • Jacob Heberlie 1 year ago
    I love the way you lure me in with "the cute-ness" and then slap me across the face with some big ass self-aware idea. Thanks :)
  •  
  • Terris 1 year ago
    Lovely. I'll share this with as many people as I can. Beautiful work.
  • Scott Benson plus 1 year ago
    Thanks!
  •  
  • Kit Lam 1 year ago
    I guess most people do not care about morality?

    I mean I hear stories here and there about designing for tobacco companies and such.. and different people respond to the job differently.

    A lot of timesa(as students), we were taught to not be so attached to their work. And that the method to deliver criticism is only done via the perspective of the work. I guess that's where the ignorance of morality deprives from this simple idea. Artists are known to differentiate work as work alone, not him or herself..

    I don't have a suggestion or a stand in this comment, however I think there are choices for artists to make before they commit to a job. I hope this will raise awareness to others!
  •  
  • Kyle Dettman pro 1 year ago
    Props, mate, for having the guts to say that. You've inspired me to draw a line.
  •  
  • versa plus 1 year ago
    agree with you, thought about it some time ago...
  •  
  • GBlayney 1 year ago
    It's the dilemma all of us are in in this line of work, but very difficult to avoid. I turned down a few lucrative jobs because I figured a clear conscience has no price...The problem is, the very nature of the work we do is essentially a deception, a means of conveying information on behalf of someone else in a way that will entice their target customers...unless of course we do it for a hobby...but we need to earn a living...

    Motion design is an essentially superficial line of work, although the results are often stunning and the ideas very clever, 95% of the time, it lacks any real substance and just provides a 'cool' factor or small entertainment value that is hitched to a product. And of course, if you do it for a living, it eats up so much time that getting to do a personal project just isn't appealing, I mean who wants to spend their spare time stuck in front of a screen? (Unless you spend the time you would have spent rebranding an arms dealer ;))

    I constantly wrestle with the morality/superficiality of this work...ideally I would just do whatever came my way and make a fortune, but I can't and I won't...

    Nice work by the way!
  • Scott Benson plus 1 year ago
    I would agree that a lot of it is superficial, in that it's essentially about nothing but a vibe or a feeling, translated into something snappy to watch. I don't know that I would call all of this type of work deception, though a lot of it certainly crosses that threshold. I really think it depends on the project and the content.

    That having been said, I think that there is something to be said for something snappy and fun. It can brighten someone's day or make them think or simply laugh. An example being the Match.com advert on my Likes list up there. I think that's a decent example of an ad that doesn't insult or necessarily lie to the viewer, and has some substance to it simply in the execution. Granted - it sells a specific view of happiness and connection and one could argue that it taps into the fear of being alone. That is an argument to be made. But their entire model is to reach out to single people and sell a service that will supposedly connect them, so I don't know how you avoid addressing the central fear tied to that concept. But through it all I think it lays its cards on the table rather nicely and actually communicates empathy more than fear. That, however is a purely subjective take.

    Oh, and I'll have my arms dealer rebrand up shortly, as soon as their massive, massive check clears and I receive the shipment of surface-to-air missiles I was promised.
  • Scott Benson plus 1 year ago
    I'd also like to point out that I didn't expect Vimeo to actually make Match . com a clickable url. WILL THE WONDERS OF VIMEO NEVER CEASE?
  •  
  • Edel Tripp 1 year ago
    You know, you put to art & design BEAUTIFULLY what Ive always thought in the back of my head when I see interesting branding loosely draped over "questionable" entities "I wonder what Art Director/Studio sold their souls to let this company borrow their art to use as a bullhorn" ...I dont have a proper blog, but I tweeted it :D Great work.
  •  
  • justin davis 9 months ago
    First of all, i know i'm posting this thing way later than i should... forgive me, i don't like crawling over the Internet, but whenever Scott puts something new out i always spend alot of time on his pages. Anyways, I think that most people have this problem in any profession. I do nothing with noticeable creativity (network engineer), but i do face these conflicts every day. I work for an awful non-profit that needs to be dissolved. I have had many opportunities to walk away, but i'm always drawn back by a few thoughts. 1. My leaving won't change anything. 2. staying there i might. 3. I'm not the one who is screwing over the taxpayers and intended support receivers. 4. I like having a job. ...and so on. Someone commented on here that people "don't care about morality." But i think this is less about outward actions and more about inward perception. I don't know, i gotta get back to work, but this subject brings up more in my mind that you (Scott) probably intended. Like, "What is art?" and other intangibles like that. Whatever. It's good. Oh, and also, i don't want to post in two places so on the subject of depression. I used to think i was depressed like those people say, but now i'm pretty sure it is just anxiety. I'm anxious about other people's choices and how they affect me. Anxious about how did someone get to the position of having the power to make a choice that affects me... and right down that line. There's a few herbs out there that helps with this. Kava, Kratom. Check them out.
  •  
  • Chris Koelsch plus 9 months ago
    Love the use of color and the style is just great. The subject hits home for me too in my daily work. Posted to my blog, This 'n That: tandtfy.blogspot.com/
  •  
  • Godmother Films plus 5 months ago
    Maybe Bill Hicks was right...
    youtube.com/watch?v=gDW_Hj2K0wo

    Thanks! It's always good to re-think about what we're doing.
    Keep up the great work!
  •  
  • Jacob Stålhammar 4 months ago
    great stuff! hear hear! :D
  •  
  • Rezgi 3 weeks ago
    Yup you're right. I remember reading in some graphic book about the responsibility of creatives in making brands "cool", thus making people support them by buying.

    I think indeed that this discussion is not loud enough, because, as you said, creativity is very powerful, it pentrates the minds and hearts of people.

    So we are responsible, because we choose to do one thing or another.

    Thanks for that great animation, and the great message behind !
  •  
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

Statistics

Date Plays Comments
Totals 6,079 180 26
Feb 23rd 1 0 0
Feb 22nd 4 0 0
Feb 21st 11 0 0
Feb 20th 4 0 0
Feb 19th 9 0 0
Feb 18th 8 1 0
Feb 17th 4 0 0

Related lessons from Vimeo Video School

Check out these lessons to learn more about how you can make videos like this one!