00:00
438
Remixing is a folk art but the techniques are the same ones used at any level of creation: copy, transform, and combine. You could even say that everything is a remix.
To support this series please visit everythingisaremix.info/donate/

Credits

Likes

  • Jacob Zawadzki 1 year ago
    Did I spot some N.W.A in there? lol
  •  
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    You sure did. :)
  • Rss?!
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    On my site you mean? It's here: feed://everythingisaremix.info/?feed=rss2
  •  
  • Sam Morrill staff 1 year ago
    This is epic!
  •  
  • Joe Ross 1 year ago
    Really a great video. Excited for the remaining four episodes.
  •  
  • Mathieu.L plus 1 year ago
    Really liked it
  •  
  • Ryan Delmar plus 1 year ago
    how did you record your audio? i can see you're a video DSLR user...
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    That’s the Behringer XM8500. 28 bucks!
  • Stu Haight 1 year ago
    lol a camera is just a tool to tell the story!

    Kirby I'm listening to music in a whole new way now, it's insane you've changed my life with this video haha!
  •  
  • This looks promising!
  •  
  • Hassan CHOP 1 year ago
    excellent research... its a cycle... an artist once told me that "there are only so many chords..." sought to explain his sampling...
  •  
  • bungle 1 year ago
    Saludos te deseo exito en tu proyecto!

    Greeting i wish you succes on your project!


    Puerto Varas, Chile, Sudamerica
  •  
  • Luca Cimarusti 1 year ago
    This is excellent....I feel like it should be noted that "When The Levee Breaks" is itself a blues cover, not written originally by Zeppelin either!
  •  
  • mpared plus 1 year ago
    love it posted at the curious brain well done :-)
  •  
  • tom weaver 1 year ago
    ... sorta like this remix of Dwarf Fortress + Girls with Glasses... everything is a remix.

    youtube.com/watch?v=9La1xxh2dmQ
  •  
  • Liam R 1 year ago
    Narrator is great!
  •  
  • Frank Hudec 1 year ago
    Great piece - Here's a Jonathan Lethem article from HARPER'S along the same line - harpers.org/archive/2007/02/0081387
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    Awesome. I'll add this to the references on my site.
  • Frank Hudec 1 year ago
    You should check out that whole issue. There were a few more articles on this theme.
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    Just read the Lethem article and it was superb. I'll try to get my hands on the full issue.
  •  
  • Thomas Paine 1 year ago
    Great video. I highly recommend you add a link to your twitter account on your site. I had to go back through the video to find the url.
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    Done!
  •  
  • Andrew Cornett plus 1 year ago
    Really great stuff!
  •  
  • Andrew Hainen 1 year ago
    Way too much time spent ripping on Zeppelin which was a pioneer for the 60's and might have been "inspired" by other bands, but weren't halfassed artists. "Good artists copy, great artists steal" - Picasso.
  • james ma redmond 2 days ago
    There's a difference in paying reverence with a tone of respect and leaving it to question whether one's borrowing riffs or whole songs with zero attribution was meant as a nod or a big fuck you.

    Think Elvis and Big Mama Thornton, if you will.

    Elvis refused to be on the same bill as her when given an opportunity and did not pay her a single red cent for his using "Hound Dog," yet Janus Joplin was light-years more compassionate with sharing the proceeds of "Little Piece of My Heart," also from Big Mama, to her.

    It's called artistic integrity, and you can argue all you like about their skills, but just remember where those skills came from, and how they paid back those influences (who were half of the Zeppelin ass you're describing) with a big fuck you.
  •  
  • Anthony Dixon 1 year ago
    Great work! I wholeheartedly agree with your point. Do you have any examples that go back beyond a single generation though? None were so blatant as Zeppelin was at the time but it be interesting to see the evolution of ideas, like a creativity version of the game telephone.
  •  
  • Luke Pygman 1 year ago
    This is incredible work!
  •  
  • Patrick Johnson plus 1 year ago
    Well produced and good insights. I'm using this in my Youtube Culture class at Boston University.
  •  
  • Nice video! If anyone wants to see a forecast of tomorrow, please watch my vids called: Dystopia!

    vimeo.com/14757576
  •  
  • Physical Law 1 year ago
    awesome video bro!!!!
  •  
  • Ignacio 1 year ago
    cool video but not anyone can remix.
  •  
  • Mario Coronado 1 year ago
    everything is a remix... even me. i am the remix of my fathers
  •  
  • kyogen 1 year ago
    reminds me of some of the concepts written about in the book The Pirates Dilemma
  •  
  • Ride or Die 1 year ago
    even religion is a remix, maybe the first true remix of all time
  •  
  • Andres Gallego 1 year ago
    Congratulations!
  •  
  • Roger Penguino 1 year ago
    Beautifully amazing work! Smart idea with wonderful editing and execution. Also this is just begging for a kickstarter.com campaign! Hope you get enough funding to continue, because it really is a mixture of great documentary, music video and academic research. Your video should be required viewing for content creators of the internet age, not to mention legislators who completely misunderstand the internet remix culture.
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    Thank Roger and great idea! I'm working on a Kickstarter campaign now.
  •  
  • Ben 1 year ago
    This is fantastic both from a documentary perspective and the well researched story you are telling.

    I never really knew all that about Led Zep
  •  
  • Brent Rose 1 year ago
    This is really excellent. Looking forward to the rest.
  •  
  • Brian Van Peski plus 1 year ago
    Great start to the series! I've added this to the documentary channel. EXCELLENT work!
  •  
  • gurkenschnitzel 1 year ago
    GREAT WORK! keep on remixing
  •  
  • paul Trott 1 year ago
    thank you, this was special. Will be back 4more.
    pt
  •  
  • Excellent, a really interesting way to look at... everything!
  •  
  • Rubèn 1 year ago
    Ah, Noel Gallagher learned this lesson so well...
  •  
  • Dhamma Āloka 1 year ago
    Synthesis 101.

    Good popular history/philosophy.
  •  
  • Tive 1 year ago
    Love this. Are you collaborating with Brett Gaylor?
  •  
  • Grip Tapes 1 year ago
    really fantastic! looking forward to part 2.
  •  
  • Casper Boermans 1 year ago
    Hmmm although i like the concept.
    The end 'standard drum riff' is, in my opinion, not really a copy..
    It's like saying that the RED london bus is copied by the fire brigade.. it's just a common thing...
  •  
  • roger batista 1 year ago
    Excelent job ! This is thrut ! 1+ºº
  •  
  • ktx 1 year ago
    well done
  •  
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    Thanks so much for the kind words everyone!
  •  
  • Dtevita 1 year ago
    Hey Kirby, this video is great, I am dealing with using found footage in my video art at university, and your video helps address and articulate my ideas around remixing and mash-up culture, thanks for your video it's so well made as well! - David from New Zealand.
  •  
  • Donna M. Daly 1 year ago
    Fascinating..who knew that about the Zep!!! Looking forward to the rest of the series Kirby!
  •  
  •  
  • Leland Cox 1 year ago
    Theres a difference between using the harmonic/melodic structure of a song and directly taking a recording which required a monetary and investment. In the case of sampling it seems fair that the recording artist that originally invested in making the recording see some compensation for their time, money and effort in the form of a percentage of net profit from the new piece (no lump sum up front).

    I'm saying this as a musician who composes, and samples.

    In an age where record sales comprise such a small portion of a Composer's income, to take away publishing income will make it virtually impossible for most composers to make a living.
  •  
  • Marshall Baltzell 1 year ago
    While the 'beat' at the end is debatable as being remixed (like saying, "I arpeggiated a C Minor, therefore I am remixing Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata") there is a bit of understanding coming from this.

    If I played the same beat on a drum machine it's just a beat.

    If I played the same beat with the intention of achieving the original sound that John Bonham had on Led Zeppelin recordings (big drums/cymbals sound, large room reverb), that would be a remix.

    All of the songs played as examples would qualify as remixes—keeping that original sound. I could find songs that have the same beat that sound nothing like it. Does this make them remixes? My answer is no.

    Great job. Looking forward to the next episodes!
  •  
  • Bia Pattoli 1 year ago
    Wow, that´s quite a lesson. Fantastic.
  •  
  • Giancarlo Morales 1 year ago
    great work !
    watch RIP:remix manifesto.
    I like your work, everything is a remix even our works!!!
  •  
  • Black Dynamite 1 year ago
    This is fantastic!
  •  
  • Horsedick .mpeg 1 year ago
    Hey Kirby,

    I thought you might find this quote inspiring.

    "Nothing is original. Steal from anywhere that resonates with inspiration or fuels your imagination. Devour old films, new films, music, books, paintings, photographs, poems, dreams, random conversations, architecture, bridges, street signs, trees, clouds, bodies of water, light and shadows. Select only things to steal from that speak directly to your soul. If you do this, your work (and theft) will be authentic.
    Authenticity is invaluable; originality is non-existent. And don't bother concealing your thievery-celebrate it if you feel like it. In any case, always remember what Jean-Luc Godard said:"It's not where you take things from- it's where you take them to." "

    - Jim Jarmusch
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    I love that quote.
  • Debbie Mar 1 year ago
    Wonderful quote!
  • BVags 1 year ago
    I'm not sure what I love more: the quote or your user name.
  •  
  • Martin G 1 year ago
    This is art!!! Congrats from Argentina :)
  •  
  • shellacsoul 1 year ago
    Good stuff, although I'd say you did take some 'artistic freedom' in using the term 'sampling' since Rapper's Delight is quite probably replayed to duplicate the original bass track (many sources say this) and it does indeed sound somewhat different. Also Daft Punk aren't sampling the track per se, but the bass melody bears some resemblance to 'Good Times'. So technically, it is definitely not sampling. Looking forward to part 2 !
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    Yeah, I've heard those points a couple times and stand corrected. I'll add corrections to the blog and perhaps a second version of the video.
  •  
  • Mckeyhan 1 year ago
    No copyright.
  •  
  • Denis Garcia 1 year ago
    Hey kirby, you had a great idea and video, and other "great" remix is the famous dance of Michael Jackson (Moonwalker)... you can show us why in the part 2.
  •  
  • Wrytr 1 year ago
    Really well done, so interesting. (I didn't know that about Led Zep.) I appreciate you delineating (starting to delineate) between what is "fair game" and what isn't. Maybe there should be a "hall of shame" for creative theft, since legal action is often so difficult for artists (especially the starving kind)?
  •  
  • Michael Tsang 1 year ago
    Can't wait for the rest of the series. You could probably do a whole series on Daft Punk alone.
  •  
  • MRGA 1 year ago
    Fantastic - I think you just summarized the Market Research Industry.

    I loved your video.
  •  
  • leighblackall 1 year ago
    The Enigma sample you included in the end, not only copied Led Zeplin, but perhaps more importantly, sampled without attribution a song by Taiwanese Aborigines, sung by Difang and Igay Duana: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Return_to_Innocence
  •  
  • leighblackall 1 year ago
    Oh, and just thought a reference to the Amen Break Beat video would be nice too youtube.com/watch?v=5SaFTm2bcac
  •  
  • Kevin Novellino 1 year ago
    right on!
  •  
  • Lee Scharfstein plus 1 year ago
    Great work, Kirby. Perhaps you can include the modern day remix-masters, Eclectic Method, in one of your episodes.
  •  
  • MagicUniverse 1 year ago
    Bravo! Very interesting material!
  •  
  • Will Caldwell plus 1 year ago
    Great work! I enjoyed the first episode. Very well done.
  •  
  • Sean Nelson staff 1 year ago
    Great stuff. Have you explored reggae at all? It's not uncommon that many, sometimes hundreds, of versions will be recorded by different artists rocking over the same popular riddim and riffing off each others lyric fragments.
    Hip Hop sampling comes directly from this tradition.

    To me it's ironic that while hip hop and reggae sample openly, these artists have taken the brunt of the "unoriginal crooks" criticisms -- while artists like Zepplin who take musics largely unknown to the general public at the time and make no effort to acknowledge their influences get sort of a free pass
  •  
  • Irineu Junior 1 year ago
    Really liked it (2)!
    #truereallytrue
  •  
  • Nyle 1 year ago
    I absolutely love this! From Hip Hop artist a just have to say thanks!

    **One SMALL note. Sugarhill Gang technically didn't sample Chic, they hired a band to replay each line, and looped it.
  •  
  • itison 1 year ago
    great work.. i look forward to more..
    you may be interested in
    remix.networkedbook.org/
  •  
  • Marcus Matyas plus 1 year ago
    Nice work! For reference, there's an interesting NFB doc available online that deals with remixes, mashups, etc. check it out ...
    nfb.ca/film/rip_a_remix_manifesto/
  •  
  • Adam Good 1 year ago
    Great video, Kirby! I think you might be interested in a project I've been working on called the Lab for Remixed Knowledge, which essentially applies remix techniques to sources and structures of knowledge: therealadamgood.com/lab/

    Cheers!
  •  
  • Marko Castanon 1 year ago
    Dayoum, nice
  •  
  • Artur Tomaszewski 1 year ago
    OK, so they copied .. but they did it GREAT !
    Still love LZ songs :)
    Great Video, thanks
  •  
  • Great Job.

    I'm an art history student, this work should become a new movement in the history of art. Keep up the work.
  •  
  • THOMAS PRIOR 1 year ago
    The guy from Led Zeppelin reminded me of Russell Brand at 2:32, the way they move their bodies
  •  
  • bopuc 1 year ago
    Good job and thanks for this effort.
    I'm just sad that this fact needs to be pointed out at all. It just shows how unconscious western culture has become. :\
  •  
  • 1od 1 year ago
    good artists copy, great artists steal.... picaso
  •  
  • August Bourre 1 year ago
    Interestingly, Zeppelin was also participating in a Blues tradition that dates back to at least the period between the two World Wars, if not all the way back to the beginning: bluesmen have always sampled bits and pieces of each others' work and passed it off as "original".

    There were covers, of course, and "answer songs" (like Muddy Waters' "Mannish Boy", which was recorded to "answer" Bo Diddley's "I'm A Man", which was itself a response to Willie Dixon's "Hoochie Coochie Man", made famous by Waters), but you'll see the lyrics to Skip James' material showing up in a hundred other Blues songs with no credit given. The same thing is done quite regularly with riffs (it's not uncommon for a Blues artist to cannibalize their own material in this way; Bukka White and RL Burnside have both recorded several variations of the same basic song under wildly different titles with considerably different lyrics and arrangments). And then there's "St James Infirmary Blues" and "Streets of Laredo", which are both remixes of the 18th Century song "The Unfortunate Rake"...

    What really sets Led Zeppelin apart is that they were outsiders to the tradition, (skillfully) appropriating both a sound and a practice. Remixing in the form you describe in this (wonderful) video, is simply a traditional Blues practice.
  •  
  • vanvinos guez 1 year ago
    ...or as XVII century scientist antoine lavoisier declared: "nothing is lost, nothing is created, everything is transformed."

    thank you so much, kirby. your work is truly enlightened
  •  
  • Eugenius 1 year ago
    potential is iminent
  •  
  • ROCmedia | IamTV plus 1 year ago
    You mentioned a translation on twitter. I never got your reaction about a Dutch translation for the video. I have a great guy with a nice voice.

    contact me: erwin@hokusfokus.nl
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    Actually, I'm just doing subtitling. Doing new voice-overs would wreak havoc with the edit. Thank you, tho!
  •  
  • project landscapes 1 year ago
    love this... for those who think they have invented the wheel
  •  
  • Jake Melara 1 year ago
    Nothing can ever be truly original due to the fact that even the greatest ideas were inspired from some other idea... that idea being inspired from another and another and another and so on
  •  
  • Iciar 1 year ago
    thanks for this! we want more!
  •  
  • Carolyn 1 year ago
    where is part 2!!!!
  • Kirby Ferguson plus 1 year ago
    Coming early Dec!
  •  
Showing 100 of 212 comments. Want to see the rest?
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

About this video

MOV
00:07:18
  • 854x480, 116.62MB
  • Uploaded Sun September 12, 2010
  • Please join or log in to download
  • License:
111 Related collections
See all 111 collections

Statistics

Date Plays Comments
Totals 1M 7,666 222
Feb 24th 0 2 0
Feb 23rd 2,282 25 0
Feb 22nd 4,167 34 0
Feb 21st 5,026 37 1
Feb 20th 6,523 66 1
Feb 19th 7,087 68 0
Feb 18th 8,698 76 1