00:00
407
More
See all Show me
2. New York Farm City
10 months ago
In order to show how vegetables are grown in New York, we reversed what the plants do: We harvest in spring what we filmed in fall.

Video:
Petrina Engelke & Raul Mandru

Music:
"Mirleft" and "Half A Decade"
from the Album "Fox Hill Lane"

by Guy Buttery
guybuttery.bandcamp.com

guybuttery.co.za


Gina and Scott Keatley
Nourishing NYC
East Harlem
nourishingnyc.org

Ben Flanner and Anastasia Plakias
Brooklyn Grange Farm
Queens
brooklyngrangefarm.com

Patrick Connolly
Bobo
Greenwich Village
bobonyc.com

Daniel Bowman Simon
People’s Garden NYC
City Hall, Manhattan
peoplesgardennyc.org
  • johannes.haverkamp 10 months ago
    Beautiful Movie!
  •  
  • rui vieira plus 10 months ago
    love it!
  •  
  • Michael Pearce 10 months ago
    i like the mixtures of styles. The "miniature" and other shots integrate well. Nicely done!
  •  
  • Adrian Glasenapp plus 10 months ago
    Very nice piece and a great story/msg.
    Would love to see you submit to clipsoffaith.com.
    Its a turn-key entry process that takes just a minute or so.
    New Belgium's Beer and Film tour is in its second year and we are especially seeking stories of sustainability and social change to share with a large audience across 16 events.

    Cheers, Adrian
    Hit me with additional questions at amg@newbelgium.com
  •  
  • arbuckle industries plus 10 months ago
    So much tilt shift! Very nice.
    I am however sometimes perplexed by the actual location of the camera to get those angles and heights.
  •  
  • James White 10 months ago
    I don't know if the lens flare starting at ~1:00 was meant to carry over to the next scene, but if it was, very impressive attention to detail. Great tilt shift also.
  •  
  • mamifero plus 10 months ago
    coisa linda!
  •  
  • G3 10 months ago
    The City Hall lawn looks good to me the way it is. Don't get me wrong, I love your idea and energy, but why not put this proposed garden on the City Hall roof, like in Chicago? Add some bees, too. Then tell the city to sell candles and honey labeled as "great gifts" and make it a two-way street. Kids can go to a roof.
  •  
  • TheBIT.TV plus 10 months ago
    Awesome video technically and subject vise.
  •  
  • Something 10 months ago
    too much contrast, but let's face it, i don't know anything about that stuff. it's just obvious that you edited the color. but the again, everyone does that.
    overall: cool. nice job, man
  •  
  • Michael Louis plus 10 months ago
    very moving emotionally and practically right on!
  •  
  • Another Cool Design plus 10 months ago
    Fantastic piece. I didnt even finish it because i felt i got the gist of it within the first 50 seconds. Cheers!
  •  
  • Kelsey Heidarian 10 months ago
    Beautifully shot!
  •  
  • Will Faulkner Films pro 10 months ago
    Awesome. Well Done
  •  
  • Lee Evans plus 10 months ago
    permaculture , nice piece , but i thought the colouring looked too graded, grading for grading sake,the plants veg etc looked artificial almost.I would have liked the grade to really have bought out the "nutritional look" of the produce.
    great message though keep it up !!
  •  
  • Jeen m Thankappan 10 months ago
    bravo!!
  •  
  • Lisa Kassner pro 10 months ago
    I like this video a lot!
  •  
  • grunasfamily 10 months ago
    Nice
  •  
  • jeriko1kenobi 10 months ago
    love it!!
  •  
  • Aidan Weltner 10 months ago
    everybody living in a city should be doing this. the video was very well put together too.
  •  
  • Timothée Gauthier 10 months ago
    THe video gave to much away too soon, as the person who stopped watching 50 seconds in was right.

    Also the audio of the interviews was to varied in quality, volume and gain should be adjusted to make them all similar, as well as removing wind/noise from the audio.

    it is alright to actually go back and redub the audio (get them into a studio to say what they had said before again exactly the same way), or if they are uncomfortable retake those shots with a better mic (a lapel mic with their back to the wind, or a boom with a good sock held low to the ground pointing up (so it isn't up in the wind or casting shadows).

    less grading would also help to make it looks a bit nicer, grade to make it cohesive, but don't grade to pop quite as much, i'd say go more for colour definition and back off a bit on saturation.

    :) Great subject, wish I could be eating them veggies with my steak tonight!
  • Timothée Gauthier 10 months ago
    also, maybe talk to them about what they do during the winter, maybe a bit how they actually DO make the growing conditions work well, go a bit deeper into the hows of the subject. make it easier for other people to get their own gardens going. Hang out with the chief more for the "whys" it is good for you, then someone else for the hows.
  • Hassan Saddiq 10 months ago
    "THe video gave to much away too soon, as the person who stopped watching 50 seconds in was right."

    just wondering, how would you have filmed/edited this video? what would you have taken out/delayed for later etc etc

    I'm just trying to see what they might have done wrong so I can learn from it

    THanks


    Ps. I watched the whole video and liked it and the story behind it
  • Nahuel882 10 months ago
    what matters is the message, not your pseudo concepts ..
  • Timothée Gauthier 10 months ago
    what IS the message? And how can one act on it?
  •  
  • David Jin 10 months ago
    wow~ gooooood!
  •  
  • Natural Causes plus 10 months ago
    love the quotes. awesome work. even more awesome shots. love your color. solid audio. thank you.
  •  
  • The New Pop plus 10 months ago
    Very cool video. I posted it on my blog along with the following blurb.

    "Their is a humble integrity that farmers exude that I think comes from living off the land. The experience of looking at their produce is akin to looking at artworks in a museum. This video by Petrina Engelke and Raul Mandru reminds me of that feeling.  Their tilt-shift..."

    TrVZ

    blog.thenewpop.com/?p=9442
  •  
  • Lori Kramer 10 months ago
    I am so inspired by this video....love the whole production and most especially the idea & the people behind the idea. Keep planting and sharing. :))
  •  
  • Mario C 10 months ago
    I wonder how LA would look like with that lense. Its looks awesome.
  •  
  • segitary 10 months ago
    do the right thing
  •  
  • electrolito 10 months ago
    inspiring =D
  •  
  • Joseph Hung plus 10 months ago
    Fantastic. Beat me to it.

    What camera setup did you shoot with?
  • Petrina TV 10 months ago
    We shot it with a 7D
    lenses:
    canon 50mm, 1.2
    tokina 11-16mm, 2.8
    canon tele 55-250mm for the tilt shift perspective,
    added the lens focal blur in After effects,

    thanks for the great feedback everyone
  • Blagger 10 months ago
    Did you add tilt-shift effect to each seperate photo in each short time lapse scene? Were they done individually or batch processed?

    Great film BTW
  • Petrina TV 10 months ago
    we used the canon tele 55-250mm all the way to 250mm for the tilt shift perspective, then added the lens blur in After Effects, by painting a mask in photoshop that would match each shot individually. Imported after the masks in AE and added them in the lens blur effect.

    We realized that it's more important to get close enough to the details and achieve the isometric perspective right that makes everything look like the Sims perspective or the illustrations of Eboy.
  •  
  • Ben Cronje 10 months ago
    Inspiring stuff. Just imagine all gardens on all city buildings
  •  
  • Redeemer Fellowship plus 10 months ago
    Inspiring. I love this film! The tilt-shift done in post looks great. Well done.
  •  
  • DSLR Feed 10 months ago
    Loved everything about this video!
  •  
  • PJ Palomaki 10 months ago
    Great piece, love the tilt-shift. Great 'earthy' feel, I guess the subject matter helps!

    The only two things that grind a bit is the audio quality and cut at times and the video has quite a few black and color flash frames which are distracting (ie. 00:34, 2:29, 3:30)

    But all in all very beautiful piece! I want some vegs for lunch now!
  •  
  • XOXO Wedding Studio plus 10 months ago
    Great video.
    Love the Time-Lapse.
    Audio sounds great too!

    But that fake lens flare at 1:00?
    And not only is the same exact lens flare used twice but back to back? I think an average viewer would notice that.
    Both shots we great awesome with out the flare.
  •  
  • Nelson Reyes 10 months ago
    Nice work!!! what camera did you use?
  •  
  • Andrew Kaplan 10 months ago
    Reminds me why I shoot on a 7D. I have to side with the producer's choice of color grading, saturation, contrast, etc. It's very clear that these elements were highly manipulated and they do draw attention to themselves. But I believe it works very well in this instance, as the atypical use of filters adds a rarefied aspect to the somewhat atypical practice of farming in one of the world's largest metropolises. For me, the effects heighten the beautiful strangeness and significance of what these people are doing every day.
  •  
  • abdul ghaffar 9 months ago
    V inspiring wonderful
  •  
  • jramos 9 months ago
    I may be doing a video similar this one for the city of Chicago. How many FPS did you shoot with the 7D, what resolution and for how long.

    Thanks for your help!
  • Petrina TV 9 months ago
    we shot at 1920x1080 24fps and the tilt shift footage is sped up at 1-2fps
  •  
  • Tomas Pir 9 months ago
    i appreciate of what are they doing.
    My observation: New York City environment has so colossal air pollution, that they can not declare the food products as ECO or BIO (even they are not using pesticides,..., as they said) otherwise it's a customer deception.
  •  
  • tareq9999 9 months ago
    Very nice video
  •  
  • Portable plus 9 months ago
    This has given us so many new places to eat and shop in the city! We featured it here portable.tv/talks/post/urban-farming-in-nyc/
  •  
  • Ana Trkulja 8 months ago
    Gardens on roofs of NYC :0) :0) :0)
  •  
  • Valentina López 8 months ago
    Absolutely beautiful!
  •  
  • Phlow plus 8 months ago
    Congrats to more than 100.000 views!
  •  
  • Marion Schönegger 8 months ago
    great! I wanna do that to when I move to San Francisco at the end of the year
  •  
  • storyful plus 8 months ago
    Thanks for sharing this on Storyful.com/community - lovely story and beautifully put together.
  •  
  • MMSH 7 months ago
    great timelapses +++++
  •  
  • Felipe Carrelli 6 months ago
    good job! love the image, the colours and the tilt shift.
  •  
  • JULIAN 4 months ago
    great job guys !!!!!!!!!
  •  
  • Arthur Sakhkalyan 2 weeks ago
    the cars pollution is lighter than the air so it goes up, on the roofs you will have an extremly polluted veggies
  •  
  • COLTO plus 2 weeks ago
    Cool !
    Check this out! this is our reality in Milan
    vimeo.com/33812986
  •  
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

Statistics

Date Plays Comments
Totals 132K 1,966 60
Feb 23rd 29 0 0
Feb 22nd 75 4 0
Feb 21st 79 2 0
Feb 20th 86 4 0
Feb 19th 79 1 0
Feb 18th 56 2 0
Feb 17th 89 1 0