This is a parliamentary debate matchup between Red Dawn A (David Reiss & Storey Clayton) and Time Desk (Dan Blynn & Rocky Lotito). It was semifinals of Columbia's recent summer tournament on June 25, 2011.

In the round, Government (Red Dawn A) proposed that, given a net utility of life, the government ought conduct an organ lottery whereby healthy individuals are killed by the government and their organs are harvested for distribution to those in need of organ donations. Opposition (Time Desk) won the round.