More
See all Show me
38. Sexy Faye
7 months ago
32. SX1-IS HD Test Footage
11 months ago
22. SONY XEL-1 OLED
1 year ago
19. Sony Rolly MP3
1 year ago
Just a little more test done with the Canon SX1 superzoom full HD combocam. Compression on YouTube for some reason does not look as good as the original file. Tried uploading twice but it did not help.Anyway, VIMEO displays better quality for the same file uploaded.

The fact that you can use the flipable LCD and also shoot video with the EVF gives you a little more flexibility.
I simply love the camera for what it's worth. On board audio is pretty good as well and is stereo.

It took alot quicker to convert the files to an intermediary c.o.d.e.c with the SX1 compared with the Mark II files though they are using the same H.264.mov / this clearly confirms the fact the SX1 records at a much lower bitrate.

The fact that you can use the flippable LCD and also shoot video with the EVF gives you a little more flexibility.
I simply love the camera for what it's worth. On board audio is pretty good as well and is stereo.

It took alot quicker to convert the files to an intermediary c.o.d.e.c with the SX1 compared with the Mark II files though they are using the same H.264.mov / this clearly confirms the fact the SX1 records at a much lower bitrate.

the SX1 compared to the XACTI has a better image stabilizer. It is easier to achieve better handheld shots from the SX1 for that reason. The xacti although has a stabilizer is inferior in terms for it uses a electronic stabilizing technology.

The xacti 1010 of course has a very interesting 300FPS function which is pretty kewl feature although does not record in HD.
More of a gimmick it make be, i find it better in video quality compared to the Casio FH20 1000 fps capability.

in terms of video quality i must confess the canon SX1 gives you better resulting video quality.

xacti 1010 however of course has more controls in terms of video shooting eg shuttter as well as aperture controls.

sx1 shoot also better photos then the 1010 anytime afterall the canon is truly a digital camera in more ways then a video camera.

battery life of the SX1 which uses the AA batteries can go on and on and never die. the xacti however has a shorted life span although it is still respectable for it uses a 3.7 volts 1900mAh rechargeable lithium ion.

SX1 is discreet when it comes to shooting video and also allows you the ability to capture the shots you want without freaking your subject. the flipable screen as well as it looking more of a camera. On the other hand point the HD1010 Xacti and you will get all the sudden stares and even ocassional. Is that a GUN he is carrying? LOL!!

Xacti has an array of format that you can select from its menu FULL HD at 1080P 720p etc etc..where as the SX1 only has the 1080p to select in HD mode.

Canon SX1 files will require a conversion to intermediary codec which is recommended however the XACTIs file with a lower setting can mean straight on your editing timeline.

SX1 has a better LCD screen in terms of resolutions and also allows shooting of video through the EVF. This prooved helpful especially when you are outdoors and in bright conditions. The XACTI only has an LCD and not a great one.

I will say one thing though and that is the both cameras have a very good SUPER MACRO capability.

At the moment that is all i can think off.

Cheers
VideoCobra
videolifestyle.com

Credits

5 Likes

Tags

  • Kilimats ☂ 11 months ago
    so you have the SX1, Mark II and HD1010 ?
    Wow lol

    Can you post your opinion on each one with pros and cons ?

    Added to the SX1 IS Channel: vimeo.com/SX1
  • Kilimats ☂ 11 months ago
    Thank you for sharing your opinion in the video description, really nice of you
  • VideoCobra 11 months ago
    you are most welcome kilimats
  •  
  • Paulo Rosa 11 months ago
    Very good video test footage.
    Also thanks very much for your opinion over the camera :)
  • VideoCobra 11 months ago
    you are most welcome paulo
  •  
  • VicentiuB 11 months ago
    " For best quality, Download the source file below (Vimeo Sign In Required) " O i'm sign'in but i don't see link for this video to download original Canon SX1 IS video , how i download it , the original not compressed
  • Kilimats ☂ 11 months ago
    If the video uploader allows it, the download link should be underneath the video main page (not visible from the channel homepage)
  •  
  • yas 11 months ago
    hi, what settings did you use to record this with your sx1?
  •  
  • yas 11 months ago
    also what conversion process , programs and codecs did you use before uploading to vimeo?
  • Kilimats ☂ 11 months ago
    check out the "Editing Advices and Questions" forum on the SX1 Channel: Vimeo.com/SX1
  • yas 11 months ago
    yeah ive checked that out but i'd be interesed in seeing what settings videocobra used for filming and what software and processes he used to convert the files. the quality of this video is probably the best i have seen out of all the sx1 videos on vimeo and youtube; and it seems videocobra is an expert in this field?
  •  
  • Thomas Wong 11 months ago
    hey, i thought sx1 has more control, can u use manual setting, and then just press the video recording button?

    i'd play the HD1000, couldn't find a manual mode.

    Which one will u recommand, I am about to get one from these two.
  • VideoCobra 11 months ago
    actually the SX1 is very much in auto in the video mode. however, if you know what you are doing you are still able to get some awesome result. as proven there are many factors and that is the lighting situation etc..there is really no secret to the results.
  • VideoCobra 11 months ago
    oh one more thing about your question XACTI has definitely more controls in the video mode and SX1 is basically more a digital still camera with just a bonus feature of video and a great one too.
  • Kilimats ☂ 11 months ago
    This is what the SX1 allow you to change for video recording

    1- Manual Exposure
    2- Manual Zoom (cannot be combined with Exposure)
    3- Color tone (like Sepia for example)
    4- Focus area

    Im sure the CHDK firmware will add and improve a lots of things
  • Thomas Wong 11 months ago
    i also notice, SX1 shoot 12minutes on a 4G card, and HD1010 can take about an hour on 4G. Plus the Aperture control on the Sanyo which can go up to F1.8

    Is the video quality a big difference? if not i think i will go for sanyo
  •  
  • Reynold Funk 10 months ago
    nice stuff derek... very do you get such natural talent from.... kids who act so normal around you... and look so good... 6 more weeks of winter here... than a cold spring... cant wait for summertime here... will have to post some footage soon.
  • TreasureProductions 10 months ago
    thanks reynold,

    can't wait to watch some of your summertime footage..
  •  
  • DavidNJ 9 months ago
    You didn't post the raw file...didn't its bitrate show the same as the 5DM2...40-45Mb/s? If it processed more rapidly (for the same subject) it may just reflect less texture detail because of the lower contrast in that area with the small sensor and inexpensive fixed lens.
  •  
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

2 Related collections

Groups Groups
Albums Albums

Statistics

  •  
    plays
    likes
    comments
  • Total
    plays 3,616
    likes 5
    comments 19
  • Dec 20th
    plays 0
    likes 0
    comments 0
  • Dec 19th
    plays 1
    likes 0
    comments 0
  • Dec 18th
    plays 2
    likes 0
    comments 0
  • Dec 17th
    plays 4
    likes 0
    comments 0
  • Dec 16th
    plays 0
    likes 0
    comments 0
  • Dec 15th
    plays 6
    likes 0
    comments 0
  • Dec 14th
    plays 2
    likes 0
    comments 0
  • Dec 13th
    plays 2
    likes 0
    comments 0
Previous Week

Downloads

Please join Vimeo or log in to download the original file. It only takes a few seconds.