
A Fistful Of Dollars: The Story of a Kiva.org Loan
10 months ago
This video follows the path of a $25 loan from London, England to Preak Tamao village, Cambodia. Kiva.org is a website that allows internet users like you or I to lend money to people that need it in developing countries, with the aim of empowering them to lift themselves out of poverty.
To find out more, go to kiva.org
To find out more, go to kiva.org
-
Vimeo: About / Blog / Developers / Jobs / Community Guidelines / Community Forums / Help Center / Site Map / Merchandise
/ Get Vimeo

Previous Week
This type of video is so great for people who want to know exactly how it works and that many people are a part of the transaction, and are carefully training and monitoring the debtor to the highest of expectations. They want to see the financial process so they can be assured they are not just giving money away; they are not just enabling or crippling someone, or are giving to people who are not hard workers. I believe these individuals have spent their entire lives focussed on earning, guarding, and identifying themselves as wealthy people with higher level life styles and owners of many things. I believe a large number of them have good hearts and would like to feel that they are contributing to the betterment of others who do not have the opportunities they had in their lives. I think they're financial success has negatively colored their view of the poor in our world. They are wary of people getting something for nothing. Some of those citizens completely believe that hard work always brings financial success, "so pull up your bootstraps and get to work." They want to know there have been some obstacles in their way, but that they are still pushing forward wth all their might and with lots of supervision to meet their goals.
My only recommendation for the next video aimed towards those mentioned above is to give a glimpse of the training and process of elimination the applicants must go through, along with an attached optional financial statement showing the records of success in different countries and of KIVA itself.
Now, speaking for people like myself who have some where around lower middle class incomes, who don't care if we get our money back everytime, we would love to see a video of a few recipients and how they live, work and the struggles and joys of their daily lives. I would love to hear their own words. I realize this is too intrusive for many, but my experience has been that there are many who would like to share their stories. Maybe it's not in KIVA's goals to expand the awareness and understanding of all the cultures of our world, but it certainly seems like it might help others to see their own enormous prosperity and to recognize how they have the ability to empower, not just to feel pity, to so many others while just giving a small amounts of money. I personally would like to know which borrowers are having harder times and still have some hope of doing better, even if they fail a few times first. I know I can look at the stars given for each loan, but I would love a pull down categories with an option of high risk instead of popularity. Well, I'm off track now. Of course the biggest gift would be to recognize the world citizens as part of our own family.
I would like to congratulate the maker of the video and encourage her to do many more. It's certainly a gift that was greatly needed. I will pass it on. our own family
This video could be the butterfly that flaps its wings on one side of the world and causes a tsunami somehwere else. Hopefully everywhere else.
My daughter and I love lending... What an inspirational organization!
Thank you for the opportunity to be part of it!
We often get asked about Kiva and how it works...this explains the whole thing much better, clearer and with more fun than I even could.
Don't want to lower the value of such initiatives (I lend through Kiva and offered a Kiva gift certificate for Christmas), but to make the circle complete, I'd love to know which company/country gets the fertilizer money and whether the chemical choice is sustainable for their soil and rivers... ;)
Keep up the great micro finance job and communicate!
I'm part of an online community where I created a tool called the "Giving Tree", inviting customers and friends to buy a leaf from it. I sponsor an entrepreneur and put their picture in front of the tree so that people know who they are helping to lift up. When they purchase the leaf, they get a framed picture with the story from Kiva and the link. This works because people are able to contribute very small amounts and yet still know they are making a tangible difference. This video you've crafted will give me one more way to make the giving "real" at a time when we are looking to scale the program up significantly for 2009. We were able to make 42 loans from April through December because of the eye-heart connection that Kiva makes possible. Your video will boost this so much more!
Thanks, Kieran, for a wonderful tool, and most especially for your leap of faith in the form of a choice to leave job security to go volunteer abroad.
Namaste,
Sue Stonebender,
The Giving Tree Program, Second Life online community.
It is so well produced that it would be wonderful to see some shorter videos of the same standard to explain Kiva quickly to newcomers to the idea and really get them excited
Good luck Kieran in your work as a Kiva Fellow
Time to make a loan! Thanks Kiva Folk!!
thanks
bravo kiva
Please make it with subtitles in different languages
Je ne regrette vraiment pas mon premier prèt .
Long life to Kiva .
I'm a Kiva Fellow, and i'd be happy to talk to you about your concerns. I have wondered about all of these questions myself and have done a lot of reading about microfinance. Check out the Microfinance Gateway website for a good source of information and research.
I wrote a post on the Kiva Fellows blog that addresses a lot of these issues and Kiva's role. The link is: fellowsblog.kiva.org/2008/12/03/how-your-loan-affects-an-mfi-behind-the-scenes-of-microfinance/
I'm not sure about the interest rate at Kieran's MFI, but I bet it's not 350%. If you google AMK Kiva, you'll find AMK's information page on the Kiva website, with information including their interest rates. They are more like 30% for Kiva clients.
I'd be happy to discuss further - just find my lender page on Kiva's site and send me a message!
d Ruiz - you are actually only the second person to question the $9 payment, and you'll be glad to know that Mrs Van Makara is not paying 350%.
She is on a special loan product from AMK designed for farmers which means that she pays interest only for the first 4 months to allow her rice crop time to yield. The $9 represents one month interest on her $300 loan, so 3% per month.
This rate is the standard AMK rate. We actually asked her and other borrowers in the area what their alternatives are and they told us either another MFI at a similar rate, or local money lenders at around 10-20% per month.
I had included all this in the video but thought it made it over-complicated so I took it out, in hindsight I should have taken the $9 bit out too as this can be confusing. It was a trade-off between providing lots of detail and making the video easier to watch, in this part I chose the latter.
In answer to your other questions, Kiva gets no interest back as this would require them to be SEC regulated, so all the interest is kept by the MFI, as is normal practice. This interest is used to cover the high transaction costs faced when giving small loans to many people in remote areas. AMK makes a small profit but all of this is retained for use in the business, it does not pay dividends to shareholders.
As Abby said above, the questions you pose are common in microfinance and the microfinance gateway and Kiva blog are great places to start learning about the different schools of thought.
I'm happy to answer any further questions you have, just message me on my Kiva page kiva.org/lender/kieran6711.
Thanks,
Kieran
I will be lending on Kiva.org very soon :)
I am a Kiva Member, and am always trying to share the joy of lending :o) . This video will make it much, much easier for others to understand! I've posted it on my Facebook profile, and have added it to my email signature, as well as embedding it into my blogs and web page.
Many thanks.
THANK YOU!
----
hghzonecenter.com