I like it. Also don't need subtitles. As for the comment above.

Beautiful cinematic style, very well done.

very very nice. heartwarming & nicely shot
super 16 is beatiful
where was it shot?

Brilliantly acted & produced profound fine gem of a short film.
I marvel at the shots and pulls, very engaging.

Excellent. From a perspective we virtually never see.

Wow. even without understanding the dialog, the feelings evoked are palpable.

This was beautifully executed.

excellent work....great lighting, fabulous editing and cinematography and thoroughly compelling with a grand sense of charm.

Wow. just wow

film......it works.......war......never works period

mint

yes. yes. more of this.
i'd say flawlessly edited.
i was impressed by how many cuts were happening
yet continuity and smoothness never lost. great sounds!
i'd write more but i've got a meeting about a prospective info-mercial with lockheed-martin in a few hours. keep up the good work!

you should be really proud of what you've done. way to go.

great

very nice. somewhat ironic that fox is involved in someway, considering its role in druming up support for the war.

I like it without subtitles. We don't need to understand a person's language to understand their humanity.

Excellent. Congratulations to the director, the message is clear, profound. We never see that kind of film.

Congratulations to you too Miky, it's the first of the 6 films I've viewed, I have to see the others, but you have a great sense of editing.

(The film perfectly works without subtitles, but I would be curious to know what they are saying, anyway...)

So powerful and moving! This is a great short film. I'm touched and moved. I will never stop thinking of war as one of the most absurd things in life.

Thank you so much for sharing.

I love your stuff man. Everything cut's together very well.

wow, beautiful cinematography...
even though i couldn't understand what they were saying, their body langauge was enough for me to understand aswell
great concept, very powerfull

wow miky. I would say that this film is the illustrative example of the power of this medium. This is the kind of work that inspired me to enter into this world in the first place. The editing here magnificently conveys the beauty, the pain and the pure spirit of humanity. don't ever let hollywood dilute your sense of beauty and timing. =)

Yes very nice short film.
"but I would be curious to know what they are saying, anyway..." Me too, how about some english subtitling?

I'm very amazed by the huge number of people (over 80!!?) that were involved with this short movie! That's about one person for every 3 seconds.

Beautiful film, both thematically and cinematographically

this is awesome,
thanks for posting!

Outstanding sound design. Great editing. Bravo!

Love it, especially the ending. Great cinematography and sound design. :)

Nice job Miky. The editing and sound design were exceptional. Its nice to see high quality content here
at VIMEO. What did you shoot it on? Again nice job..

I'm in AWE...beautiful short showing the real side of war and the people most effected.