00:00
162
More
See all Show me
Vergleich der Schärfentiefe mit verschiedenen Brennweiten und Blenden, links die XH-A1, rechts die 5D Mark II. Mehr unter videoslr.de

Comparison of depth of field of the Canon XH-A1 and the Canon 5D Mark II with different focal lengths and aperture values.

Credits

Likes

See all likes
  • PappasArts 2 years ago
    Thanks for doing this test. Very much appreciated....
  •  
  • Barlow Elton 2 years ago
    Let me second that--thank you very much.

    Wow, the look of the two is so radically different. The A1 highlight blowouts were quite telling, and that's not even taking DOF into account.
  • videoslr.de 2 years ago
    Interestingly, I cannot tell myself really where the blown-out highlights are coming from, because the XH-A1 was set to low contrast (cinegamma).
  •  
  • sam phibbs 2 years ago
    Hey rad test what picture profile settings were you using on the 5d I like how it is not as saturated and seems to have good latitude. Makes the xha1 look so video despite the obvious dof differences.
  • videoslr.de 2 years ago
    Picture profile was as follows: Sharpness 0 (slider all the way to the left), saturation lowest, contrast lowest and color shift(? - the one at the bottom) -1.

    I like the way the 5DMk2 renders colors, too.
  •  
  • Nice comparison! Apples to apples!!! The 5D looks soooooo much interesting!
  •  
  • Mike Kobal plus 2 years ago
    vielen dank fuer den test.
  •  
  • Chris Higham 2 years ago
    excellent test
  •  
  • rCHANCESm 2 years ago
    finally a comparison...I have the xha1 and Im thinking of purchasing the 5d.
  •  
  • Laura & Val Feytser plus 2 years ago
    I'm glad I found this video. Thanks videoslr.de
  •  
  • Heli N8 2 years ago
    The 5D is no where near as sharp image as it can be and I've seen. I have an XH-A1 but want a 5D as well
  •  
  • The Penguin 2 years ago
    Danke für den Test, ich habe zwischen einer XH A1 und der 5D geschwankt, jetzt wird es wohl die VDSLR. ;)
  •  
  • Transcendent Films plus 2 years ago
    Stick a Letus on the end of the XH-A1 and it will tell a very different story! I'm happy with my XH-A1/Letus set up and wouldn't buy the 5D-MkII. I did buy a Casio Exlim F1 for high speed work and gives me the portability of a full HD SLR movie camera.
  •  
  • VJ SAW 1 year ago
    For sure the 5D got a DOF (buy the way u can get a quite nice DOF if u zoom with th XH-A1, but I know its not allways possible) Waht I see its that the 5D picture all in all is motre blury than the xh-a1....ore Im wrong?
  •  
  • San John 1 year ago
    Hie Also mire ist aufgeffalen das die XH-A1 mehr Raum sharf stellt, und die 5D ein Objekt scharfstellt, was denken sie ? Welche ist die bessere Kamera und filme oder Music Videos zu drehen ?
  •  
  • videoslr.de 1 year ago
    gta78130:

    Für mich ist das keine Frage, die 5DII.

    VJ SAW:

    Yes, you could get the impression of blurriness. That may come from: Shallow depth of field, not the whole subject is in focus; my first steps with the 5DII, so maybe I misfocussed a little bit in one or two images and last: You could still sharpen the image in post, but I prefer the more natural look in comparison to the "over-sharp" pictures from the XH-A1.
  •  
  • mediatainment 1 year ago
    danke für den Test!
  •  
  • chmee phreekz* 1 year ago
    Keine Frage, die Videofunktionen der DSLRs sind ein Traum, aber SORRY, sofort fällt die höhere Grundschärfe der XHA1 auf, die meisten fallen einfach nur auf Filmlook und Freistellen rein.
  •  
  • krrz 1 year ago
    sehr guter test
  •  
  • William Dean plus 1 year ago
    Never seen a 5d MKII video that soft.
  •  
  • Gian Nicola Beraldo 5 months ago
    Thank you for your video! If I look at the blur behind the lady, I have to think that the 5D is simply out of focus...
  •  
  • D.D. 2 weeks ago
    Also mir gefällt die Schärfe der XH-A1 besser! Ich wollte eigentlich wechseln.
  •  
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

About this video

FLV
00:02:42
  • 1280x720, 20.06MB
  • Uploaded Sat May 02, 2009
  • Please join or log in to download
1 Related collection

Statistics

Date Plays Comments
Totals 12.6K 28 22
Feb 14th 8 0 0
Feb 13th 10 0 0
Feb 12th 9 0 0
Feb 11th 7 0 0
Feb 10th 4 0 0
Feb 9th 2 0 0
Feb 8th 10 0 0

Related lessons from Vimeo Video School

Check out these lessons to learn more about how you can make videos like this one!