00:00
188
More
See all Show me
5. Ben Goldacre on Homeopathy
2 years ago
4. Joe
2 years ago
3. Condor Robot
2 years ago
UK students will soon be sitting an Ideas in Context Biology paper, which this year focuses on homeopathic medicine. In our film, Guardian columnist and best-selling author Ben Goldacre gives his views on the science and ethics of this branch of alternative medicine and looks into the fascinating puzzle of the placebo effect.

Credits

Likes

See all likes
  • Arlo 2 years ago
    Excellent short and to the point explanation on why Homeopathy simply doesn't make any sense.

    Good job, I've been passing it around. Or, maybe I shouldn't pass it around. Maybe if I don't pass it around at all, it'll have a stronger effect? :)
  •  
  • Davy Drysdale plus 20 hours ago
    Well, Ben - It seems to work in many cases — and it kills no one.
    Unlike Conventional Medicine, which Kills many Thousands in the UK every Year.
    The first principle of medicine is "Do No Harm" , a principle which has been, sadly, overlooked.
    Now, Allopathic Medicine is very Mechanical, it tends to ignore the Psyche & Mind.
    The Doctor of Old had a Good "Bed Side Manner" - which basically meant He was great at inspiring Sick People to get better - even though he knew he had no medication to help them get better.
    This frequently worked very well, and helped many people back to Health.
    You, as a GP should understand this concept - which Scientists call Psychoneuroimmunology.
    If Homoeopathy works for a group of people, but you don't understand why, surely it's prudent to stand back and observe the people who are getting better - listen to them, examine them and see the changes that are taking place in their physiology & pathology - instead of slagging off a form of Medicine that obviously works.
    On the Continent - Germany, Switzerland & Austria - No one questions that Homoeopathy helps with many conditions. Sadly in the UK, where the Medical Profession are stuck in 7 minute consultations and "Drug Only Solutions" - they fail time and again to help.
    The remedies that Homoeopaths offer may only be a Placebo, but they get great results, as they are Great Medical Practitioners - Visit the Glasgow Homoeopathic Hospital at Gartnaval, before small minded Idiots destroy a wonderful institution that has helped 1000's of very Ill People back to health.
    Do bear in mind that many Drugs used every day in the NHS by Doctors are as perplexing to explain as any Homoeopathic remedy.
  •  
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

About this video

MP4
00:03:08
  • 640x480, 19.19MB
  • Uploaded Thu May 21, 2009
  • Please join or log in to download
1 Related collection

Statistics

Date Plays Comments
Totals 10.3K 16 2
Feb 23rd 0 0 0
Feb 22nd 3 0 1
Feb 21st 14 0 0
Feb 20th 1 0 0
Feb 19th 1 0 0
Feb 18th 2 0 0
Feb 17th 1 0 0