00:00
386
Produced by Panos Pictures, with photographs by Ian Teh, this is a journey into some of China's most industrialised cities, a journey to the other side of the bright shiny facade that is the economy. It is a glimpse of another life and another world that is rarely seen.

China's economy is exploding and behind the scenes of this economic miracle is the industrial revolution powered by the cheap labour that is helping to build and sustain the economy. Coal for power, coal for steel, coal for cement. Coal and labour are the raw materials, the flip side and the dark side of this economic juggernaut that is China. But it comes at a heavy price for the country's environment and its people's health. And now that is has overtaken the US as the biggest producer of carbon dioxide, China's emission levels will increase anxiety about its role in driving man-made global warming and will add to pressure on the world's politicians to reach an agreement on climate change that includes the Chinese economy.

Please credit Panos Pictures
To see more of Panos Pictures work go to panos.co.uk
For more of Ian's work go to ianteh.com

Credits

Likes

See all likes
  • Philippe Clairo 2 years ago
    Sort of an Asian Blade Runner environment! When money takes over people's lives... chilling. Nice work.
  •  
  • Walter Fischer plus 2 years ago
    It is easy to put the dark side of the chinese wakeup industry in a bad corner- but please dont forget: pictures like seen here are courant normale in france, germany, great britain and other high civilisised countrys. It is a little bit cheap to shown the mistakes of followers in dramatic pictures, sorry.
  •  
  • Rodger Benner Jr. 2 years ago
    Amazing!!!
  •  
  • Paco Hermosillo 2 years ago
    Beautiful image But Bad intentions, bad agenda
  •  
  • Simon Packman 2 years ago
    This is amazing. Great work. What film stock did you use? and any photoshop or post? I'd like to know! it has a unique look almost artificial.
  •  
  • omar zubair 2 years ago
    amazing photos and vitally important topic, but the soundtrack to this is cartoonishly dramatic and dangerously stereotypical. it lets us (unconsciously?) categorize this in the same way we would a death scene in a hollywood film [though, like a death scene in a hollywood movie, it really hurts before becoming just emotional background noise about 10 seconds later]. i think a little sonic empathy with the situation, rather than finely-polished bravado, would really help the cause. [feel free to have this conversation with me.]
  •  
  • Tsering 2 years ago
    I drove there two years ago. It was really shocking. Thanks for the amazing work up there!
  •  
  • Eddy Sun 2 years ago
    I don't think it's amazing. No achievement comes out without a price. China is developing at an amzing speed, it's reasonable that there will be some environmental cost. Just like the developing time of America, a lot of forest got destroyed, a lot of workers were at a extremely bad condition. So it's not amazing. It's just the real process of development.
  • Michael Hanlon plus 2 years ago
    "It's just the real process of development. "

    ..and the real cost of development.
  • Eddy Sun 2 years ago
    I learned that when America was developing in the early 20th century, the situation was far worse than that! Workers were working in the extremely bad working condition, and the environment was badly polluted. You can get more pictures about what it was real like when America was developing. And you will know what I mean "It's just the real process of development." The same things appears in every country, not only in China.
  •  
  • Vaucluse HD plus 2 years ago
    Very nice pictures of exploding industry in China !
    As Eddy says, it s just a real process of development.
  •  
  • Benjamin Tsui 2 years ago
    Great pictures but honestly you can't put scary music to some pretty normal pictures and really have much validity to your argument. Some of the photos could have easily been the case in China's developed areas like Shanghai and Beijing. People playing pool is as luxury. These coal miners have jobs. I am not trying to refute your argument, in fact I agree with you, but you surely should find better photos that can aptly show the severity of the pollution.
  •  
  • lisa.liang 2 years ago
    thank you for your job.
    that awakes us the dangerous these people do.
    any way ,you have got the good eyes.
  •  
  • Paco Rubio 2 years ago
    Great job. To you all who say that the author is exaggerating: get informed. China is not even democratic. The information we get and the alarming data are already filtered; we don't know what really happens in China half the time. It is a dangerous place, with very harsh and even cruel communism-related attitudes. For instance, all the baby girls that are systematically assassinated at birth as a measure of population control. China is much scarier than this video shows, people.
  • Eddy Sun 2 years ago
    Oh my god! Are you dreaming??!! I'm a Chinese, and I can tell you responsiblly, ABSOLUTELY NOT!!
    We have the "One Child policy", but the government just encourage families have only one baby, they never, and will never kill babies for population control! You're crazy...
    We live very happy life here. It's very safe and harmony. Not like America, we don't have access to guns, and murdering and robbing is rarely happend. Our Communist Party government treat us really good. Schools, hospitals, roads and every other facilities are well built. Some negative information was filerted, that's true. But this just make us more united. Our government did really good contribution when the financial crysis came. We didn't lose our jobs or have any financial problem, not at all. BUT, look at America... Look at YOUR DEMOCRATIC GOVERNMENT! IT SUCKS. Your government is so impotent at this financial crysis time. So, Communist Party is good at most time. You just saw the very little and mean view of it, and your knowledge of China is really limited, gentleman... You're dreaming...
  •  
  • Ray Anderson 2 years ago
    You've stirred up a bit of a hornet's nest--one man's truth is another man's histrionics--but I think you've done a fine job. Gives folks something to chew on.
  •  
  • Sunny Thaper 2 years ago
    Beautiful photos.
  •  
  • Matias Canelson 2 years ago
    Great work, the pictures are amazing, I sent this video to my friends.

    I would like to see some tech specs of the video because the image quality (titles+pictures) is superb (codecs, frame size, etc)
  •  
  • ian teh 2 years ago
    Interesting to read the comments. I would like to clarify my intentions about this multi-media presentation:

    1) It's not about finger-pointing or China-bashing. It's just about highlighting a global environmental issue in which China, as the world's number one polluter, is a major player and for which we all have a collective responsibility. That's the point I was trying to make by saying "if the modern lifestyles of the ‘new’ China are representative of OUR [my capitals] collective dreams for a better life then these images of industry, are a surreal testament to our ambitions."

    2) Visually (and musically) I wanted to play on the notion of China's economic 'dream' by showing, as a counterpoint, the surreal, 'nightmare' on the opposite side of the coin. The purpose was to expose a reality in which the choice is limited to earning a meagre and dangerous living or starvation. These anonymous people form a vast population of cheap labour help to realize China's current unprecedented boom. They are "the candles who burn themselves in order to give light to others" to quote a labourer who lives in the Shanxi region.
  • Eddy Sun 2 years ago
    I agree with your idea, but not totally.
    You should consider that the population is really high,and that led to extremely high competition. Some less-educated workers have no choice, for some reasons, but to do some dangerous and less-paid job. That's true. But there will be great changes in a few years. Because China is developing very fast, and this developing-stage will be a history.
    Look at your American old photos, you will find the same view happend in your developing time. It's all the same. So it's meaningless criticizing China. It's just the natural developing process. And China is more beautiful and harmonious than you thought. I'm a Chinese guy and I know what's my home country really like.
  • Eddy Sun 2 years ago
    And in addition, your photo works are really good.
  • ian teh 2 years ago
    Thanks for your messages.

    By the way I lived in China for a year and a half and I have been traveling there since 1995 at least once a year. So, far from disliking China or perceiving it to be something negative, I actually am very fond of it and have had more than a passing interest with it. I think China and its people have many great qualities. America and Europe on a per capita basis produce far more CO2 than the average Chinese so the West can hardly point its finger, but there needs to be an awareness of the issues and its cost to its own people, its environment and the world. After all, it is only when we are aware of a problem that we can correct it. I think its appropriate and necessary to document and express these concerns. I wouldn't hesitate to do the same in my country or any other for that matter but it just so happens I am very interested in China. Just because the work does not show China in its best light in this context it does not have to mean that its whole image is tarnished. Nor should you think that I am American and hate China. In fact its quite the opposite. It might interest you that I am Chinese by descent and that my wife is a Chinese from China but I don't really think that any of that should really matter.
  • Eddy Sun 2 years ago
    You're right...
    Maybe I just overreacted because of the other comments appeared in this page...
    Looking forward to your new works...
    Best wishes to you and your wife.
  • rhythmnblues 2 years ago
    I like the words "the candles who burn themselves in order to give light to others", typical saying that I heard since in elementary school. The photographs Ian shows us are definitely truth, in Shanxi, one of main coal-mining centers, we have to admit this, what you people usually saw is the specious development of China, however, the country has a population of 1.3 billion, what you saw just a small part, 2008 Olympic Games gives china a good chance to show its best view to all the world, but we have to admit there are plenty of places like Ian's photos of Shanxi in China, poor people have to be burning candles for a living, this is the inevitable situation occurs in a 1.3 billion population developing country. And I think it's unfair to discuss this case with high developed countrys' standard. I like these photos but the background music is too depressing, I will embed this video in my blog to share it to more people. Thanks.
  •  
  • Belle Provence plus 2 years ago
    Smart choice : atmosphere, colors, and sounds. Very expressive.
  •  
  • rick fiduccia plus 2 years ago
    Earth First !
    We’ll strip mine the rest of the planets later. . .
  •  
  • Susan Heredia 2 years ago
    Your subject matter is chilling, and had my heart racing. It was apparent that these people are perhaps willingly ignored for the progress of the rest. Your experience of photographing the cities and people must have been draining, was it ever dangerous?
  • ian teh 2 years ago
    Yes and No. I mean it had its moments but for the most part I was lucky I never came across anything I couldn't cope with...so sometimes I feel I wasn't tested beyond what I could deal with thankfully. Overall it had its moments but for the most part I felt fine and I met some amazing people.
  •  
  • moni storz 2 years ago
    hi
    i love them all, so lyrical, so much you and i am still organising your exhibition in Melb... your works should be seen by more people.
  •  
  • Very good fotos , nice composition too.
    What camera is used?
    Hope your message included is understood.
  •  
  • airbil 2 years ago
    Okay well now, this is what independent film can do. In this case; open our eyes to what we already knew or suspected.
    Great use of imagery, colors and music to make a point.
    Nice work!
  •  
  • Eddy Sun 2 years ago
    China is far more beautiful than what you guys thought. If you have any wondering or question about China, I'm glad to show the truth to you guys.
    My MSN number is : snakesun1990@hotmail.com
  •  
  • ANTONIO ELIA 2 years ago
    terrible should stop all this
  •  
  • Sansom Media 2 years ago
    Wonderful work! Great story and well editing. I would typically have an image moving when it comes on screen but there are a few times when they begin cropping in a second or two before the move begins. Its almost like my eyes get to wander for a moment and then you as the storyteller says, "look here:

    Like of the week!

    likeoftheweek.blogspot.com
  •  
  • Really good job, I really like it.
    Just a question: Do you have J visa?
  •  
  • Robert 2 years ago
    "It was a town of red brick, or of brick that would have been red if the smoke and ashes had allowed it; but, as matters stood it was a town of unnatural red and black like the painted face of a savage. It was a town of machinery and tall chimneys, out of which interminable serpents of smoke trailed themselves for ever and ever, and never got uncoiled. It had a black canal in it, and a river that ran purple with ill-smelling dye, and vast piles of building full of windows where there was a rattling and a trembling all day long.."

    -Hard Times, by Charles Dickens
  •  
  • wayne eardley plus 2 years ago
    These are beautiful images of the world we live in. In my mind this could be anywhere. I have photographed in China but dident have the balls to get this close. Congratulations!
  •  
  • Yao 2 years ago
    I am a Chinese guy and strong agree that 'Eddy Sun' said.
    "It's just the real process of development."
    Just the same as other countries!
  •  
  • Chance 2 years ago
    well the good news is global warming doesn't have anything to do with CO2 emissions, so you can sleep a little easier knowing that.

    The working conditions suck and people get sick, but that's just an effect of globalization and pockets of corruption within the Chinese government. So we have to change our conception of economics first and get rid of free trade and all that silly stuff.

    Nuclear power is awesome though, no CO2 and you get fresh water as a by product.

    :)

    good photos, silly content.
  •  
  • num3ric 2 years ago
    Wonderful pictures!
    How did you gain access to these sites?
  •  
  • kellie lee 1 year ago
    in china the commie waste tax payer's money to block the resource like vimeo
  •  
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

Statistics

Date Plays Comments
Totals 28.7K 268 41
Feb 14th 2 0 0
Feb 13th 2 0 0
Feb 12th 7 0 0
Feb 11th 9 0 0
Feb 10th 11 0 0
Feb 9th 7 0 0
Feb 8th 13 0 0

Related lessons from Vimeo Video School

Check out these lessons to learn more about how you can make videos like this one!