.
The Clock in HD - 24p vs 60i test footage HV20
9 months ago
More
32. The Clock in HD - 24…
9 months ago
this is my first real 24p video on vimeo so far... wanted to use the same footage but shot in 24p mode as well as 60i mode. Hopefully I did it right :) Please shoot me down if i didn't! The .mp4 in this video is 24p and 60i version is here (30p really but shot in 60i): vimeo.com/597154 . the 60i version doesn't have the closeup footage. only had that for the 24p version.
Note: You can't tell the difference on Vimeo. You would have to download the .mp4's and play them.
Camera: Canon HV20
Editing: Adobe Premiere Pro CS3
Pulldown method: Eugenia's awesome tutorial. Very nice! You can view it here:
eugenia.gnomefiles.org/2007/07/13/canon-hv20-24p-pulldown/
Note: You can't tell the difference on Vimeo. You would have to download the .mp4's and play them.
Camera: Canon HV20
Editing: Adobe Premiere Pro CS3
Pulldown method: Eugenia's awesome tutorial. Very nice! You can view it here:
eugenia.gnomefiles.org/2007/07/13/canon-hv20-24p-pulldown/
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.
-
playslikescomments
-
Total
1,986 
1 
8 -
Oct 7th 1
0 
0 -
Oct 6th 3 0 0
-
Oct 5th 4 0 0
-
Oct 4th 3 0 0
-
Oct 3rd
0 0 0 -
Oct 2nd 5 0 0
-
Oct 1st 1 0 0
-
Sep 30th 3 0 0
Previous Week
See referrers
Please join Vimeo or log in to download the original file. It only takes a few seconds.
- Vimeo: About / Blog / Roadmap / Developers / Community Guidelines / Forums / Toys / Help! / Site Map
- Legal: ©2008 Vimeo, LLC / Terms & Conditions / Privacy Statement
I guess it's because of what Eugenia said above... or maybe due to a lack of color (??) in the subject.
Either way, both are beautiful. You could shoot a blade of grass w/the HV20 and it will look great.
i'm not sure i'm ready to jump on the 24p bandwagon just yet. i don't see a huge reason to shoot my footage in 24p just yet. unless it's low light. i'm mostly a videographer, not an editor, so i like the 60i footage personally. and as you can see, i'm mostly into nature and outside shots... where 24p probably won't come into play too much. but at least i know how now :)
i will try to get some more color and contrast. thanks,
I see a definite difference in the wood grain under the shelf above the clock. The 24p version looks like it had black stretch on while the 60i looks less differentiated.
I have noticed on my old Sony V1 that clips shot with the same preset and everything except shutter speed look richer, warmer, more natural in 24p.
a lot of people said i should do this outside to give this a fair comparison as well. something with a lot of colors etc... so i'll redo this. white and bland colors, you probably won't see a huge difference.