00:00
526
More
See all Show me
In November the Global Conversation focuses on the prosperity gospel—the teaching that true Christian faith results in material wealth and physical well-being. While it has its roots in America, it has found fertile soil on other continents as well. To accompany the lead article in Christianity Today by Ghanaian scholar Kwabena Asamoah-Gyadu, director Nathan Clarke went to Ghana to explore the forms the prosperity gospel takes in that West African nation.

Read about the "behind the scenes" story - bit.ly/1oRzUb

Credits

Likes

See all likes
  • Chris Sinclair plus 2 years ago
    this was really well done. didn't pull any punches. looked at things honestly (love the first person perspective). this is the sort of thing that others would usually point at and say 'yeah christianity is pretty invalid' like Jesus Camp or something. but you told the story in a way that made me actually appreciate the REAL Christ MORE by your balanced awareness of who was out of the picture as much as in it.
    well done.
  • Thanks Chris - I appreciate your comments.
  •  
  • Chronicle Project 2 years ago
    We like this.
  •  
  • Midnight Cry plus 2 years ago
    Very well done. This is tragic, demonic, a complete misrepresentation of the gospel of Christ. Having lived in Africa for some time (2005-2006) you see the impact that this US-exported form of religion has firsthand. False promises, disappointment, recklessness and the like are the foundations of this teaching.

    How men can rape the poorest of the poor like this is the very heart of darkness.

    The man who claimed that God told him to "make sure they give in dollars!"... what can you possibly say?
  • Thanks for your comments Midnight Cry. One of the unexpected discoveries of my time in Africa was the role that prosperity teaching plays in helping people develop better work patterns. Wiser people have equated it to a new type of protestant work ethic. While some prosperity gospel teachers say that your financial blessings will come with sacrificial giving (like the first guy in the video) others encourage people to work hard and apply themselves (the second pastor.) In my life, my family played that role (and my mom played it well when she never let me quit the soccer team I wanted to abandon.) In Africa, that system is compromised because of a variety of factors like poverty and AIDS. So this teaching is filling that vacuum. It's an interesting element to what is becoming in my mind a very complex problem
    -Nathan Clarke
  • Nathan Clarke plus 2 years ago
    Heather - at the risk of being defensive, I did not say that the Gospel only teaches a "better work ethic." Heavens no!! I believe if you read my post, I state that this concept of work ethic has been a by-product of the "prosperity gospel." I am all for holistic approaches to mission, in fact one of the stories we will be telling as part of the Global Conversation is a very inspiring example of meeting all sorts of needs in Northern Thailand. You can see that in a couple of months.

    In regards to your other question about the documentary length, this is it. I'd love to pursue this story more and if we can find funding, that might be an option.
  •  
  • Jerrold Daniels 2 years ago
    Thank you for this! It brings a whole new dynamic to the conversation when it's taken to the global scale. We have been having an ongoing dialog about this very subject on our blog and we'd love insight from others who are educated in this area. tinyurl.com/yj32obo
  •  
  • Jonathan Moss 2 years ago
    What is the song that begins at 2:45? It's extremely good. And as a whole, the video was incredible.

    Incredible and so sad. Thanks for putting this up and making us aware of the prosperity gospel and the damage that is being done outside of America.
  • Jonathan, thanks for your kind words.
    The music is production music - no artist that you can buy off the street.
  •  
  • P. Higgins 2 years ago
    Great/sad video.....beautifully shot. The first pastor's white shoes are stellar. Unfortunately, Nordstrom doesn't carry them, but I will keep looking.
  • Nathan Clarke plus 2 years ago
    Perhaps prayer will help you in your quest
  •  
  • btz.lt 2 years ago
    Thank you!
  •  
  • Paula Rennie 2 years ago
    Very nicely done Nate, but the preachiness induced something akin to a bad acid flashback :). I must say, I'd never seen a preacher in white lace, but the shoes came close to the sartorial excess of one bloated buffoon I had the great misfortune to see not once, but twice. I'm allergic to most "gospels", the prosperity gospel in particular, and I've always wondered how those who buy into it and fail financially feel - abandoned? It's a cure for one guy's poverty - the one in the shoes.
    Keep up the really great work!
    Auntie P.
  • Nathan Clarke plus 2 years ago
    Thanks Paula. I'd love to do a piece that profiles people that are in the "audience" and buy into it, but for this project, time did not allow for that. I think it would make for an interesting documentary - the prosperity gospel from the other side - a bottom up view.
  • Paula Rennie 2 years ago
    Exactly!
  •  
  • Feingut 2 years ago
    "Jonathan, thanks for your kind words.
    The music is production music - no artist that you can buy off the street."

    Who produced it?
  •  
  • Steve@316 2 years ago
    Anytime someone has added ANYTHING before the word "Gospel", it is no gospel at all. Breaks my heart.
    gnpcb.org/esv/search/?q=1+Corinthians+15%3A1-11
  •  
  • Heather Harden 2 years ago
    Steve, you are so right. There is only one Gospel and that is the one given to us by Jesus Christ through His infalliable word, the Bible.
  •  
  • Daniel Seely 2 years ago
    Great video! I am currently living and ministering in Africa and have seen first-hand the long term effects and mindset that the prosperity gospel produces. People are "coming to Jesus" not because they have been regenerated or are responding to the grace of God but because they want something for themselves. Now I'm not saying that it's wrong for genuinely poor people to desire to have their physical needs met, but it is absolutely wrong to twist the true gospel so that people respond to get their needs met.

    The prosperity "gospel" is one of those "another gospel[s]" that Paul talks about in Gal 1:6-9. It takes the eternal message of Christ and perverts it with a message of immediate, physical, and material blessings. For those who say that desiring and praying for and "craving prosperity is non-negotiable," what about 1 Timothy 6:6-11? They must ignore or twist this passage to continue preaching like they are.

    These prosperity preachers are literally robbing from the poor by giving false promises of material blessings which they say are sure to come "if you have enough faith" - a faith which must be evidenced by giving money to these false prophets so they can get rich.
  •  
  • chosen 2 years ago
    As one born and raised in Nigeria, I can say that this is so true. The prosperity gospel has become mainstream, and many pastors think its okay to change cars every three years while many in their congregation cannot even afford three square meals.
    I like your approach, quite objective. Good video.
  •  
  • Jonathan Ciawy Tay 2 years ago
    Many more vids like this are needed!!!!! The message is not only urgent but also well presented, using a first person view that brings you into the action as opposed to... up there. And also, love the contrast between the preacher's leather shoes and the congregation member's thongs. And yet he asked them for more money!!! Disgusting!
  •  
  • OM USA Video plus 1 year ago
    Thank you for this.
  •  
  • WLPictograph plus 1 year ago
    Great! Long overdue... thanks.
  •  
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

About this video

MOV
00:08:46
  • 1280x720, 325.36MB
  • Uploaded Thu October 22, 2009
  • Please join or log in to download

Statistics

Date Plays Comments
Totals 34.4K 55 24
Feb 11th 2 0 0
Feb 10th 4 0 0
Feb 9th 20 0 0
Feb 8th 9 0 0
Feb 7th 24 0 0
Feb 6th 37 0 0
Feb 5th 4 0 0

Related lessons from Vimeo Video School

Check out these lessons to learn more about how you can make videos like this one!