Looking great so far Carlos. The lights are what get me.....well a lot of things get to me..birds..bike..flowers...love. :-)

Quite simply brilliant Carlos.

It's made SO beautiful! And while I was watching, i didn't ask myself all the time how it was animated, I just enjoyed. That's the best that can happen! :D

Wonderful Carlos. I felt it was slightly odd that the adults were 2D....but then it was the little girl imagining them so it kinda made sense. Colour and light are stunning.

You have such great lighting in all of you pieces, I am curious as to your process for this animation in particular, what are the characters made of?

Stunning! Really SO well made, absolute Art

Carlos,
Truly, one of the most beautiful I've ever seen.
Beautyful story, colours, effects, and movements...
You are very talented!!
Why no in HD??
Congratulations,

Davide

I loved it. beautiful!

At the risk of repeating what people have said: the lighting is simply stunning! Great Job!

I also really liked the way you change from one kind of animation to another.

Carlos, las particulas de polvo en el aire hacen que ese ambiente surealista desaparezca y nos haga sentir a los personajes como reales seres humanos y a nosotros dentro de ese mundo.

Exquisite! Lighting and detail are incredible.

this is gorgeous, carlos. i love the blend of different animation techniques, and the color and lighting is stunning.

Wow! The sound effects, music, shading, use of depth of field/focus, and all were very, very nice!

wow, absolutely amazing!

Awesome.

I'd say you could work a bit on the audio mixing. The overall piece is a little loud, especially the birds, so I would work on the mixing a bit . The mix to the different part of the Sigur Ros song was well done though.

Thats my only suggestion, otherwise the animation is just freaking fantastic and very original.

stunning. outstanding work.

Hola Carlos muy buenos tus trabajos de animacion una facinacion. trabajas con muchas personas en estas animaciones,para uno solo lo veo heavy no jaja,muy buena la sony v1.
quisiera saber por ahi tenes mas informacion que yo si a una pc pentium 4 se le puede poner sistema operativo de mac el leopard.
gracias saludos.

Incredible work...extremely well done. I would very much like to see the finished work

Very awesome. Powerful stuff

I am impressed!

Que belleza de video !
Muy profesional.Felicitaciones!

A very sweet short film that is captivating... Thanks for posting.

WoW! That was simply amazing...

Another fabulous piece.

sigur 4 ever. so icelandic :_)

Amazing. Nice work.

You are so talented !!! I can't wait to see the final work. Brilliant, just brilliant. Bravo !!!

That totally stoked me. My only criticism is I would have liked to hear more ambient sounds and some more SFX. Beautiful camera moves.

Holy crap! You've got to be kidding me! This is the best thing I've seen on Vimeo so far. Incredible work.

incredible.

wowsers trousers. congratulations.

This is so breath taking. The sound cues is amazing.

Wow! This is mind blowing.

So beautiful.

i think this is the most amazing stop-motion i've ever seen! WOW!

Flawless! This is truly amazing, beautiful, touching, I could go on and on!!

Masterly job.

madremia!!!!

es precioso...

:)

Very nice! I like the peace.

great! best I have seen.

Men, you rock

brillante! tu eres un director fantastico.

me gusta los colores y los aves.

Very well done... ^_^

I loved it!

very impresive!! keep it up

Naaaaw that's so cute... and pretty...

The lighting and the music really make this film magical.
Very sweet.

Nice Job!

Thanks, just great !

Beautiful... Just beautiful.

wow, the lighting and the colors...
really, really beautiful!

Love the style, love the effects. Would be very fun to go about it :3 <3

this is why i love vimeo

gran trabajo. guión magnífico, que no necesita palabras, personajes precisos, claros, hermosos
y la imagen, stop motion con una fotografía excelente y muy muy bien postproducido.

un ejemplo del que aprender. congratulations. Y que viva el talento del sur

Great film
I love the whole old fashion cinima effect added to it
From me it gets the thumbs up

totally genius!

Carlos, you are a very talented human being.

You my friend are an incredible artist. Bravo.

Thanks for your production photos alongside your video. You definitely make me glad I've joined Vimeo. The quality of your work in this layout usually isn't found except on a personal site. Glad to be on a network where creativity like yours can be found and enjoyed.

Where do I get tickets to its festival debut?!?! WOW!

I agree with Pimpdaddysupreme, Vimeo shines because of the talents of people like you.

That was incredible! Great work man!

I am simply mute. Really realy really beautiful. 1:21 to 1:29 was stunning light and i mean STUNNING.... I have becoma a fan :)

I loved this film--well done

Hi everyone!

Thank you so much for the kind comments you all posted. I´m glad that
you liked the short.

I intended to reply to every comment personally, but I never thought I
would get so many!

I´m now working full time on some new material that I will post as
soon as it´s finished.

Thank you all, keep up the good work guys!

Carlos.

Bravo!!!

Great!!Good work!!

Congratulations

it's really a beautiful and well paced work.
good luck with it!

Wonderful! So beautifully constructed that tears come to my eyes!

I've watched this short three times now. It is so nice to see something so simple express so much love, and hope for what's to come. Bravo and well done sir.

So sweet ^_^. I loved the way u mixed things up, not just the animationm techniques but also the music with noises. Lovely! xoxo

i just cried when i watched it . i love it , thanks Carlos!

Wonderful. I love it.
:D

I feel like a broken record saying "Gorgeous, gorgeous, gorgeous" to every video on this website, but I'm certainly not complaining.

Terrific film. I look forward to the finished product. The sound design is lovely--the bird sounds over the music were really captivating.
Also, thanks for posting some production photos! Very interesting and inspiring. I figured there was some compositing, but I had no idea there was chroma keying within the scenes. Excellent work.

i fell in love with your movie
keep on the good work

amazing.
beautiful.

just wow!

Does anybody know the title of music played in the short?

Wowww! Carlos!! awesome!!! i love the work in the lights!! that have a kind of viscosity , Which software used?, the animation it´s very good!, i have this work like a reference.

Example of light "viscosity" en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:BlackHole_Lensing_2.gif

Greetings!!
PD: Sorry for my poor english!! :p

Ahhh sos Argentino... ok, muy buen laburo loco, increible la verdad.

Un abrazo desde Mendoza, Argentina!

This is Spectacular

you got something here mate, really well done (: whhheeeeeyyyaboom .

pure amazing

It's so beautiful~!I love the little girl's eyes~
It's like the truth.
(I can speak just a litthe English)

Just beautiful

Awesome!

Fantástico che! Felicidades!

astig! (amazing!) so beautiful...

Excellent animation!

Love this! To be able to give life complete with eye and finger expression showing emotion from a twined wire-built character is amazing.

The expression in the faces.. wonderful.