00:00
2457
More
See all Show me
1. Blue Gold: The Tsilhqot'in Fight for Teztan Biny (…
1 year ago
~ Winner of two Honourable Mentions for Best Conservation Message and Best Use of Natural Sound in the Montana CINE International Film Festival! ~

Blue Gold expresses the Tsilhqot'in peoples' unanimous rejection of Taseko Mines Ltd.'s proposal to drain Teztan Biny (Fish Lake) in order to stockpile mining waste.

"It is not possible for us to agree to the destruction of the land that sustains us." ~ Chief Marilyn Baptiste, Xeni Gwet'in First Nation.

One of RAVEN’s first projects was supporting the Tsilhqot’in National Government and Xeni Gwet’in First Nation in their legal action against the proposed – and ill-named – Prosperity Mine. The project that Taseko Mines Ltd. wanted to push through would have destroyed the lake and filled the area with toxic waste. The lake is sacred to the Tsilhqot’in and Xeni Gwet’in First Nation and is part of a pristine watershed that runs to the Fraser River.

RAVEN raised funds – with the generous support of Friends of the Nemaiah Valley, Donner Canadian Foundation, Small Change Fund and Global Greengrants – to produce the short film Blue Gold: The Tsilhqot’in Fight for Teztan Biny. The film gave voice to the Tsilhqot’in’s unanimous opposition to the mine and was shown to the federal environmental review panel at the public hearings in Williams Lake, BC (which we believe to be a Canadian first – to have a documentary shown as part of a federal environmental review).

RAVEN worked with other environmental groups to raise funds when there was not enough money to pay the experts to attend the federal hearings. Thanks to the amazing support of our online donors, we raised the funds needed in just three weeks to ensure the people with the technical expertise were present to explain scientifically why the Prosperity plan was deeply flawed. And RAVEN received much needed financial support from the Fitzhenry Family Foundation to cover the legal costs of writing the final submissions on behalf of the Tsilhqot’in.

We celebrated with the Tsilhqot’in when the CEAA panel issued its final report. Based on the overwhelming evidence brought forward during public hearings, the independent Panel concluded that mine would have “cumulative high and irreversible impacts” in a number of areas, including Tsilhqot'in people and culture, that the false “Prosperity Lake” could not begin to meet DFO's requirements for “no net loss”, that the impacts on blue-listed (endangered) grizzly bears would also be cumulative and irreversible, and that navigation under the Navigable Waters Protection Act would be impossible.

The Panel also clearly described what would be at stake for the Tsilhqot'in people: "The Panel has determined that the loss of Teztan Biny (Fish Lake) and Nabas areas for current use activities, ceremonies, teaching, and cultural and spiritual practices would be irreversible, of high magnitude and have a long term effect on the Tsilhqot'in" [Report, p. 203]. The Panel confirmed that "the island in Teztan Biny (Fish Lake), which would be destroyed by the mine waste storage area, is a place of spiritual power and healing for the Tsilhqot'in."

It worked!

On November 2nd, Environment Minister Jim Prentice announced that cabinet had rejected the mine! In a news release, the Environment Minister stated, "...the significant adverse environmental effects of the Prosperity project cannot be justified as it is currently proposed." Jim Prentice went on to say: The Prosperity project has also undergone a thorough review process, including an environmental assessment by the province of British Columbia and a Federal Review Panel under the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act. In making its decision, the Government of Canada took into consideration the conclusions of the report of the Federal Review Panel, and agreed with the Panel's conclusions about the environmental impacts of the project.

Congratulations to the Tsilhqot'in National Government and Xeni Gwet’in First Nation! And thank you to all those who supported them in this monumental fight.

For more information about RAVEN's work, please visit our website at raventrust.com

Credits

Likes

See all likes
  • Susan Smitten plus 1 year ago
    Great news!! The federal panel ruled in favour of allowing this film into the public hearings. They will screen it Wednesday night (March 24th). And based on Taseko's submission that there was no precedent for allowing a film as evidence, I believe this may well be a Canadian first for documentaries - being shown in a federal hearing as evidence.

    Taseko fought hard to keep this film out of the public hearing - calling it propaganda. Watch for yourself and decide.
  •  
  • Susan Smitten plus 1 year ago
    The federal environmental review panel found that the Prosperity Mine Project will have "significant adverse effects" on the environment, and "high magnitude, long term irreversible" impacts on Tsilhqot'in people and culture. But the report is non-binding - and the public campaign has begun in earnest by the pro-mine camp to convince the federal government that the project should go forward despite the panel's findings.

    This is a watershed moment for First Nations’ cultures and environmental protection in Canada. The independent Panel concluded that this Project will result in devastating impacts on productive fisheries and threatened grizzly bear populations, and the permanent loss of an “important cultural and spiritual area” and a “place of spiritual power and healing” for the Tsilhqot’in people. Federal Cabinet needs to know that this is a line that cannot be crossed.

    Please spread the word. And visit the RAVEN website - raventrust.com - where there are email addresses and a sample letter. The battle was won, but the war is not yet over.
  •  
  • Gerard Lavoie 1 year ago
    My company is only a few years old, but I have taken a real interest in how to help raise public awareness about this kind of ecological destruction. I think that if there hasn't been a high resolution bathymetric survey completed to assess the turnover of the lake, there is no real way to assess it's value. You really should find this out. first nation's should insist on this as an absolute bare minimum mapping component. The full spectrum of value has not yet been assessed, and for that reason, this project should at least be delayed. First Nations needs to quantify natural resource values independently of the federal government in order survive in this capitalistic era. I really hope that it will pass with the fall of the USA.
  •  
  • Susan Smitten plus 1 year ago
    Victory for the Tsilhqot'in! On November 2nd, the Canadian government rejected Taseko's Prosperity Mine, saying the 'scathing' report from CEAA made it impossible to give the go ahead. We all rejoice with the Tsilhqot'in people at this momentous decision!!
  •  
  • Susan Smitten plus 1 year ago
    Also, Blue Gold won two Honorable Mentions at the Montana CINE International Film Festival, for Best Conservation Message and Best Use of Natural Sound!!

    Yay team!
  •  
  • barb dawson 1 year ago
    So Happy for our mother earth!!
  •  
  • stephen st laurent 2 months ago
    Awesome. I'm hoping that the new proposal gets turned down as well.

    Check out the film we made about Amazay...

    youtube.com/watch?v=pypoI54tLxg

    I was giving a talk with the environmental planning students up at UNBC and they asked me about the new Prosperity proposal... sounds almost like the old one...
  • Susan Smitten plus 2 months ago
    Thanks Stephen - I was grateful to watch your film a couple of years ago at a screening here in Victoria - it was a kick off to the work we did in the first round of saving Fish Lake. And you are correct that the so-called 'new' proposal is like the old one. That's because it was their plan B - a worse option by Taseko's own admission - and it was rejected by CEAA and Taseko in the first round. Somehow it is now an acceptable option for them to put forward.
  •  
  • Susan Smitten plus 2 months ago
    An update: The fight to save Teztan Biny (Fish Lake) is on again in earnest. As noted in the comment above, Taseko Mines has resubmitted a plan - a worse option than the one that was rejected - and it is now going to be reviewed by the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA). In addition, the province issued permits to allow Taseko to go in and build roads and drill at 59 sites, in advance of the federal EA. So now the Tsilhoqot'in are in court, trying to get injunctions to prevent this from occurring.

    RAVEN is now launching a second round of calls for help for the Tsilhqot'in - setting up a legal defence fund and raising the much needed funds to cover both the court applications and the experts and reports that will be needed for the upcoming CEAA review. Please share this and if you can assist with this effort, your energy, time, resources will be gratefully received!

    Tax-deductible donations can be made online at the RAVEN website, raventrust.com.
  •  
  • Susan Smitten plus 2 months ago
    And in case it isn't clear, all the legal costs for this - from preparing arguments to having a lawyer stand in court, to hiring experts to research and write the scientific reports needed for the hearing, to getting the elders in to testify ALL cost money that must be paid by the Tsilhqot'in. They bear this burden alone. There is no legal aid. Government does not pay for this. They just launch the process and then it is up to the band to pay for it.
  •  
  • Bryce Behrhorst 2 months ago
    I wanted ask since your videos focused on First Nation communities fighting Big Corporations Companies, do you have any plans in filming North Eastern B.C First Nations in their battle with the "Shale Gale" industry and their amazingly rapid development. The natural gas industry according my to studies in incredibly premature, since its inception its only been 15 years. This is a bad scenario is anything will go wrong in these communities.

    But I would just like to know, it seems that you have a good thing going here. Thank you very much!!
  • Susan Smitten plus 2 months ago
    Helly Bryce - unfortunately no, I don't have plans to film there. It's a good story - so others may be working on it. I just don't have the resources or time to add another one to my plate! Thanks for writing... best of luck!
  •  
  • Susan Smitten plus 2 months ago
    On Friday, the Tsilhqot'in won an injunction against Taseko Mines - it was a spectacular victory. Xeni Gwet'in Chief Marilyn Baptiste was granted an injunction to stop exploration at the proposed mine site. And Taseko's application for an injunction preventing the Tsilhqot'in from blockading the road was rejected.

    Justice Grauer dismissed Taseko's claim that delays would cause irreparable harm to the firm and instead ruled that without the injunction, the Tsilhqot'in would lose their right to be meaningfully consulted forever, and that "preservation of the area is vital" while the "gold and copper is not going anywhere."

    This is a temporary win, that allows the Tsilhqpt'in time to consult and to raise the funds they will need for the second environmental review.
  •  
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

About this video

MP4
00:40:57
  • 720x480, 820.6MB
  • Uploaded Tue February 23, 2010
  • Please join or log in to download

Statistics

Date Plays Comments
Totals 10.5K 23 13
Feb 13th 1 0 0
Feb 12th 7 0 0
Feb 11th 3 0 0
Feb 10th 12 0 0
Feb 9th 6 0 0
Feb 8th 7 0 0
Feb 7th 10 0 0