Patrick Wharen Sr. and Kelly Wharen were high school sweethearts. Years later, Kelly introduced 19-year-old Jonathan Vuick to her husband as their future son-in-law. Vuick was allegedly the fiancee to Kelly's long-lost daughter that no one had ever seen. On April 4, 2008, Patrick Wharen Sr. shot and killed his wife and Vuick after suspecting they were having an affair. In the process, Wharen Sr. shot his own son in the chest. His son survived and would later testify at his dad's trial. Wharen Sr. was convicted of two counts of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison. In this video, the open that previewed our programming.