In 1980's Brighton Beach, Olga Nikolaevna a Russian emigre and high school teacher, screens a hopelessly romantic Soviet film to her captive audience of teenage students. But in a class of streetwise American kids, only one pupil truly gets it. Soaking up the image of a picture-perfect captain that comes on a ship with scarlet sails to rescue his humble bride, young Katya begins her earnest search for true love. Years later, after a string of tragi-comic cataclysms in her love life, 34 year-old Katya still refuses to give up faith in her teacher's promise that she will find her picture-perfect captain. Until the day when Katya unexpectedly meets Olga once again...