Cast of participant architects:
A production by Office for Strategic Spaces (OSS)
Director and Producer: Angel Borrego Cubero
Technical Director and Editor: Simon Lund
Assistants to edition: Gaël Urzáiz, Cristina Hortigüela
Music: popular song: “When Johnny comes marching home”
Musical arrangements and production: César Bartolomé
Solo voice: Saira Mir; Flute and piccolo: Nayra Adrian ; Clarinet: Javier Llopis Boquer
Cameras: Gaël Urzáiz, Loreto García, Sara Verd, Simon Lund, Angel Borrego Cubero
Funding and collaborations: Fundación Arte y Derecho, Govern d’Andorra, Lord Culture, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, Ateliers Jean Nouvel, Dominique Perrault Architecture, Zaha Hadid Architects, Gehry Partners
Date of World Premier: October 10th 2013 at the Architecture Film Festival Rotterdam (AFFR)
Date of final edit release: October 25th 2014 at Filmoteca Española - Cine Doré (Spanish Film Archives)
An almost uncomfortable but intensely fascinating account of how some of the best architects in the world, design giants like Jean Nouvel or Frank Gehry, toil, struggle and strategize to beat the competition. While nearly as old as the profession itself, architectural competitions became a social, political and cultural phenomenon of the post-Guggenheim Bilbao museums and real estate bubbles of the recent past. Taking place at the dramatic moment in which the bubble became a crisis, this is the first one to be documented, in excruciatingly raw detail. But does the jury have the last word?
Jean Nouvel, Frank Gehry, Dominique Perrault, Zaha Hadid and Norman Foster are selected to participate in the design of the future National Museum of Art of Andorra, a first in the Pyrenees small country. Norman Foster drops out of the competition after a change in the rules that allow the documentary to happen. Three months of design work go into the making of the different proposals, while, behind doors, a power struggle between the different architects and the client has a profound impact on the level of transparency granted by each office to the resident documentary crew, and which has a definite influence in the material shown in the film.
The presentations to the jury happen in one intense day close to election time in Andorra, becoming a hot event in the tiny country, with media all around the international stars that may help shape its future. Of the four remaining architects three show up to make personal presentations, every one of which becomes a fascinating study in personality, strategy, character, showmanship… and a dramatic moment in which any detail becomes both important and irrelevant, the line between failure and success perfectly imperceptible
Angel Borrego Cubero (Spain, 1967). While trained in architecture, with a PhD from ETSA Madrid and a MArch from Princeton University, where he was a Fulbright scholar, Borrego Cubero has been developing an interdisciplinary body of works that deal with issues such as the contemporary urban condition, the negotiations between private and public space, violence, surveillance, fictions in architecture, etc.
After succeeding in a big international competition, in a process which was akin to a thriller, Angel Borrego Cubero decides to make a documentary of this recurring architectural procedure. During four years, intense work was dedicated to find, document and edit one into film format. “The Competition” is the first feature documentary of this Spanish director and is also the first film documenting the tense developments that characterize architectural contests.
On April 20, 2013, SCI-Arc celebrated its 40th anniversary with a party that was as unconventional as the school’s approach to architecture education. Alongside brightly color-coded polygonal tables and galleries of some of the year’s best student work, 330 alumni, trustees, faculty, and friends joined all four SCI-Arc directors to raise nearly $400,000 for student scholarships.
The benefit dinner celebrated SCI-Arc’s forty years of innovation and architectural experimentation, and the school’s mission to find radically new responses to the needs and aspirations of today’s world.
Interviewees (in alphabetical order)
Hernan Diaz Alonso
Neil M. Denari
Eric Owen Moss
Eric Owen Moss
Hernan Diaz Alonso
Director of Photography: Michael Halper
In New York State, 16 & 17 year old offenders are prosecuted as adults in
the criminal justice system. These young people often face life long criminal
records and incarceration alongside adult offenders.
Rather than deterring youth crime, this harsh sentencing scheme
increases the likelihood of recidivism among adolescents. In fact, jail sentences and criminal records have been shown to deter positive behavioral change in young people.
In 2012, a pilot program called Young New Yorkers was launched to offer an
arts-based restorative justice alternative to a group of young men caught
up in the criminal justice system. youngnewyorkers.org